Judging craft items by unity and wholeness of form
If the form of an item is coherent, all its parts fit one another and serve one purpose. Wholeness means that the sum of the parts looks like one finished unit: no part feels extra or foreign. Before judging, criteria are set: harmony of form, proportion of parts, suitability of the material for the itemās purpose, quality of workmanship, placement of the pattern and ease of use. For judging, at least two items of one kind and equal size are taken and discussed openly and freely. Each student gives points by the criteria and writes a conclusion, so a mark must be backed by reasons. In class āI like itā is not enough: you must explain through a criterion why you like it.
Classmates looked at pictures of two vessels and rated them on shape, proportion and pattern. It was soon clear that on one the pattern did not suit the shape, and they could say why.
Designers and craftspeople judge the form of an item against criteria, exhibition judges compare works fairly, and masters look critically at their own work.
Next time you see two pictures, books or notebook covers side by side, say why you prefer one, using words like āshapeā, āsizeā or āpatternā and not just āI like itā.
āJudging panelā: the class judges two chosen items (or their pictures) by a criteria table. Each group announces its scores and gives a one-sentence reason. Sharp or breakable items are shown only in pictures.