Morality and law
Morality is the set of rules of conduct, often unwritten, that people follow based on shared ideas of what is good or bad and fair or unfair. Law is a system of rules adopted or recognised by the state, enforced by state power and binding on everyone. The differences: the state sets the law, whereas morality forms in society by itself; if law is broken the state applies compulsion and punishment, while breaches of morality are mainly judged by public opinion; law is written precisely in documents, morality may be unwritten; in law conduct is judged “lawful – unlawful”, in morality “good – bad”. They work in the same direction: law is largely formed on the basis of morality. In its “objective” sense law is the sum of legal norms; in its “subjective” sense it is a right belonging to a particular person (for example the right to housing or education). Law performs three functions: regulating, protecting and educating.
| Aspect | Morality | Law |
|---|---|---|
| Who sets it | Forms by itself in society | Adopted or recognised by the state |
| If broken | Mainly public opinion judges it | The state applies compulsion and punishment |
| Written form | May be unwritten | Clearly written in documents |
| Assessment | Good – bad | Lawful – unlawful |
A pupil finds someone’s lost wallet and hands it to a teacher. This is morally right, and the law also requires found property to be returned to its owner. Morality and law sometimes support each other.
A police officer helps return found items to owners, a teacher teaches honesty, and a school counsellor talks with pupils about right and wrong choices.
Choose one rule you follow and ask yourself: ‘Would I still follow it if nobody saw me, and why?’ Think about whether your answer rests on morals or on fear of a penalty.
| Situation | Morality | Law |
|---|---|---|
| Revealing a secret a friend trusted you with | Contrary | Usually no punishment provided |
| Stealing someone’s phone | Contrary | An offence – the state holds liable |
“Morality or law?”: the teacher reads 10 rules (giving up a seat to an elder, paying taxes, greeting, obeying traffic rules, respecting a teacher...). Pupils mark “M” (morality), “L” (law) or “both” and discuss that some rules belong to both.