I. S. Turgenev. «Певцы»
«Певцы» is a story from Turgenev’s cycle «Записки охотника». On a scorching July day the narrator comes to the village of Kolotovka and hears that peasants are gathering at the «Притынный кабачок» for a contest between two famous singers, Yashka-Turok and a contractor from Zhizdra. The contractor sings first: he is skilful and light, he trills in a falsetto, and the listeners approve. Yakov begins quietly with a trembling voice and gradually moves everyone, even the stern Dikiy-Barin, to tears. The climax comes when Yakov ends on a high note as if his voice had snapped: everybody falls silent, and the contractor says “You have won” and leaves the room. The story shows the talent and the beauty of soul of ordinary people.
In a talent show the judges assessed two performers: one played every note exactly, the other moved the audience. The judges said that both skill and feeling are needed. The story likewise shows the value of real feeling in performance.
Judges, music teachers and critics assess both the skill and the effect of a performance.
Recall two performances you have heard and write in one Russian sentence which moved you more: «Мне больше понравилось …, потому что …».
“Two songs”. Two groups prepare three-sentence speeches, one for skill and one for feeling; the class discusses which is more moving.