Ways of expressing rules
There are several ways to state a rule. 1) The imperative: Keep your desk tidy. 2) Must / mustn’t for strong obligation or a ban: Pupils must carry their school cards. Pupils mustn’t use phones in tests. 3) Should / shouldn’t for weaker rules or advice: Pupils should keep their desks tidy. 4) The passive, when the doer is not important: No bicycles should be left in the corridor. Eating is not allowed in the lab. Cheating is forbidden. 5) is allowed / is not allowed / are expected to. Must and have to differ: must is the speaker’s own authority, have to is an outside obligation. Mustn’t = a ban, don’t have to = not necessary.
| Way | Example |
|---|---|
| imperative | Keep your desk tidy. |
| must / mustn’t | Pupils mustn’t use phones in tests. |
| should / shouldn’t | Pupils should keep their desks tidy. |
| passive | Food is not allowed in the library. |
A sign at a sports hall said, “Shoes must be removed before entering the hall.” A pupil who read it took off their shoes and helped keep the hall clean.
Building managers, hotel staff and people who write public signs also give rules in the passive.
Find a notice at home or school and decide which form it uses: imperative, “must” or passive. Then rewrite it in a different form.
| mustn’t | don’t have to |
|---|---|
| it is forbidden | it is not necessary |
| You mustn’t copy in a test. | You don’t have to wear sports shoes on Monday. |
“Rule detective”: the teacher reads eight rules in different forms; pupils decide if each is imperative, must, should or passive.