2
Two boxes: Carroll diagrams
Learner’s Book 1: Unit 14, pp. 205–209
GoalSort things into the two columns of a Carroll diagram.
New words
Carroll diagram · a table with two boxes for sortingcolumn · a box that goes up and downnot · the opposite of the rule
Explanation
A Carroll diagram is another way to sort things. It is a table with two columns. The label on the left column is the rule, for example ‘has a handle’. The label on the right column says ‘no handle’, which is everything that does not match. Every thing goes in one column only, never in both. When you have finished, count each column to see which has more.
| Has a handle | No handle |
|---|---|
Worked examples
| Has a handle | No handle |
|---|---|
| cup | ball |
| bag | plate |
| jug | apple |
| Bigger than 9 | 9 or less |
|---|---|
| 12 | 3 |
| 15 | 8 |
| 10 | 5 |
| Has corners | No corners |
|---|---|
| square | circle |
| triangle | oval |
Class activity
Sock and shoe sorting: draw a big Carroll diagram on paper with the rule ‘has laces’. Sort 8 things from the shoe rack or the toy box. Count each column. Then change the rule and sort again.
Practice
1
Sort into the diagram: hen, stone, fish, chair, tree, ball. Which are alive?
| Alive | Not alive |
|---|---|
hen, fish and tree
2
How many things have wings?
| Has wings | No wings |
|---|---|
| bird | dog |
| bee | fish |
| bat | |
| plane |
4 (bird, bee, bat, plane)
3
Where does the number 14 go?
| Bigger than 9 | 9 or less |
|---|---|
In ‘bigger than 9’.
4
Ali puts a sock in the ‘has a handle’ column. Is he right?
No. A sock has no handle, so it goes in ‘no handle’.