GoalCompare the effects of surface area, temperature and concentration on a reaction, and plan a fair test of one of them.
New words
variable · something that can change in an investigationfair test · a test in which only one variable is changedtotal amount of product · how much is made in the end, which depends on the limiting reactantpredict · say what you expect, with a reason
Explanation
There are three main ways to make a reaction faster: use smaller pieces of a solid (a bigger surface area), raise the temperature, or use a stronger solution. All three make successful collisions more frequent. Temperature also makes each collision more energetic. None of them changes the final amount of product, if the amount of the limiting reactant stays the same. A stronger solution gives more product only if the solution holds the limiting reactant and its total amount is increased. A fair test changes only one variable and keeps the others the same, and measures at the same times. If two variables are changed together, you cannot tell which one caused the difference. In industry, workers speed a reaction only up to the point that is safe and affordable: powders can ignite, hot mixtures need energy, and strong chemicals are dangerous.
Change
What it does to the particles
Collisions
Final amount of product
smaller pieces of a solid
more of the solid is exposed
more frequent
same
higher temperature
particles move faster and hit harder
more frequent and more energetic
same
stronger solution
more particles in each cm³
more frequent
same, unless the solution holds the limiting reactant and its amount is raised
Worked examples
One reaction under three sets of conditions, with the same mass of the same solid and acid in excess. The graph shows the volume of gas: X is cool lumps, Y is warm lumps and Z is warm powder. All three end at 48 cm³. The average rate in the first 30 s: X 0.27 cm³/s, Y 0.50 cm³/s, Z 0.93 cm³/s.
Pair
First run
Second run
A
lumps, 50% acid, 20 °C
powder, 50% acid, 20 °C
B
lumps, 50% acid, 20 °C
powder, 50% acid, 40 °C
C
powder, 50% acid, 20 °C
powder, 100% acid, 20 °C
Which comparisons are fair? Pair A changes only the state of the solid, so it tests surface area fairly. Pair B changes both the state and the temperature, so it tests nothing. Pair C changes only the acid strength, so it tests concentration fairly.
mass and size of the solid, the volume of acid, temperature, the same equipment
reliability
three runs for each strength and a mean
Planning a test of concentration. The solid is in excess so that concentration is the only thing that limits the starting rate.
Class activity
Card match. With an adult. The adult cuts 8 pieces of paper. On four write conditions: ‘powder, not lumps’; ‘warmer water’; ‘stronger acid’; ‘more of the limiting reactant’. On the other four write effects: ‘more particles exposed at the surface’; ‘particles move faster and hit harder’; ‘more acid particles in each cm³’; ‘more product at the end’. Shuffle them and match each condition to the effect that explains it. For each pair say whether it changes the rate, the amount of product, or both. Then add two new conditions of your own (for example ‘a bigger flask’) and say whether they matter. Check each other’s answers.
Practice
1
A pupil wants the gas from a fixed amount of limestone and acid as fast as possible, safely. Name two changes and say how each gives more successful collisions.
Crush the limestone to a powder (larger surface area, so more collisions with acid particles) and warm the mixture a little (faster particles, more frequent and more energetic collisions). A stronger acid would also work (more acid particles in each cm³).
2
Look at the table. Change the second run in pair Q so that the pair becomes a fair test of temperature. What would any difference in speed then tell you?
Pair
First run
Second run
Q
powder, 25% acid, 20 °C
powder, 100% acid, 40 °C
The second run should be powder, 25% acid, 40 °C, so that only the temperature differs from the first run (20 °C). Then any difference in speed between the two runs is down to temperature alone.
3
Look at the lesson graph. Why do all three lines end at 48 cm³?
The same mass of the same solid was used with acid in excess, so the amount of limiting reactant was the same. The changes only change how fast it is used up.
4
A pupil plans a test of concentration like this: ‘2 g of lumps with 25% acid in the first run, and 3 g of powder with 100% acid in the second.’ Find the faults and write a corrected plan.
Three things are changed at once: the mass of the solid, the state of the solid and the acid strength. The same mass and form of solid must be used (for example 2 g of powder both times), with the same volume of acid at the same temperature, and only the acid strength changed (25% and 100%).