GoalDescribe the stages of the collision (giant-impact) hypothesis for the Moon, and explain why scientists call it a hypothesis.
New words
hypothesis · a possible explanation that can be tested against evidencecollision · a crash in which two objects hit each otherdebris · broken pieces of rock and dust thrown out by an impactTheia · the name scientists give to the Mars-sized object that may have hit the young Earth
Explanation
Nobody saw the Moon form, so scientists look for the explanation that fits the evidence best. The leading explanation is the giant-impact hypothesis, also called the collision theory. Scientists think that about 4.5 billion years ago, not long after the Earth formed, a young planet about the size of Mars crashed into it. The impact was so violent that rock from both bodies was melted and thrown out into space. Much of this debris went into orbit round the Earth as a ring. Over time, gravity pulled the pieces together into one ball, and scientists think that ball became the Moon. The details are still being worked out, and computer models are used to test different versions of the story. This is why we write ‘scientists think’ and not ‘we know’.
a Mars-sized object approaches the young Earth→impact: rock from both is melted and thrown into space→a ring of debris orbits the Earth→gravity pulls the debris together→the Moon forms
Worked examples
Stage
What happens
Idea behind it
1
the object moves towards Earth
gravity pulls the two bodies together
2
the object hits Earth
energy of movement becomes thermal energy, so rock melts
3
debris is thrown out and orbits Earth
pieces stay in orbit round the Earth
4
the debris clumps into one ball
gravity pulls the pieces together
The four main stages, with the idea behind each one.
Statement
Fact or hypothesis?
The Moon orbits the Earth.
fact
Space missions have brought back Moon rock.
fact
A Mars-sized object hit the young Earth.
hypothesis (supported by evidence)
The Moon formed from the debris of an impact.
hypothesis (supported by evidence)
Sorting statements. A fact has been measured or observed. A hypothesis is an explanation that scientists test.
How big was the object? Mars is about 6800 km across and the Earth about 12 700 km, so the object was about half as wide as the Earth: far bigger than any asteroid. The Moon (about 3500 km) is added for comparison.
Class activity
Splash and debris. With an adult, outdoors or on a large tray inside a big box. Pour flour about 3 cm deep into a baking tray, level it with a ruler, and dust a thin layer of cocoa powder on top. Drop a marble from 20 cm and look at the pattern, then level the flour and drop it from 40 cm. Do not blow on the flour. Predict first: will a higher drop make a wider crater? Measure the width of each crater, repeat each height twice, and record the results in a table. Keep the marble, the flour depth and the levelling the same each time. Wash your hands afterwards. This is a model: it shows that an impact throws material outwards, but real impacts melt rock, are much bigger and the debris is held in orbit by gravity. Name two other limits of the model.
Practice
1
Which two of these statements belong to the collision hypothesis?
Letter
Statement
A
the Moon formed far away and was caught by the Earth’s gravity
B
debris from an impact formed a ring round the Earth
C
gravity pulled the debris together into one ball
D
the Moon was thrown off a fast-spinning Earth
B and C. A is the capture hypothesis and D is the fission hypothesis.
2
Mars is about 6800 km wide and the Earth about 12 700 km wide. About what fraction of the Earth’s width was a Mars-sized object?
Planet
Diameter (km)
Mars
6800
Earth
12 700
6800 ÷ 12 700 ≈ 0.54, so a little more than half.
3
After the impact, the debris first formed a ring round the Earth, but the Moon is a single ball. Explain why the debris did not stay as a ring.
Every piece of debris has gravity, so the pieces attract each other and clump together. Over time they gathered into one ball, which scientists think became the Moon.
4
A news headline says: ‘We know the Moon was made by a crash.’ Rewrite it so that it matches the state of the evidence, and say why your version is better.
For example: ‘Scientists think the Moon formed after a crash.’ Nobody saw it happen; the idea is the best explanation of the evidence so far, and new evidence could change it.