Using the reactivity series and displacement reactions
Week 17 · Unit 5 · 5.2 · 3 lessons
1
Clues to a mystery metal
Workbook 9: Topic 5.2, pp. 91–93
GoalUse the results of displacement tests to say where an unknown metal fits in the reactivity series, and choose a metal that will displace another.
New words
candidate · a metal that could still be the unknown one, because it fits every clue so farnarrow down · to remove possibilities one by one with each new resultrecover · to get back a useful substance from a mixture or a waste liquidscrap metal · old metal objects that are collected to be used again
Explanation
Every displacement test gives one clue. If metal X displaces metal M from its compound, X is more reactive than M, so X sits above M in the series. If X does not displace M, X is below M (or the reaction is too slow to see). Two clues make a bracket, and the metals inside the bracket are the candidates. Each new test narrows the list down. The same rule helps you choose a metal for a job: pick one above the metal you want to push out, but not one that reacts with water, such as sodium or calcium, because it would react with the solution first. Cost matters too, so cheap scrap iron is used to recover copper from the waste water of copper mines. Displacement tests are done by a teacher, not by a learner.
Clue
What it tells you
Where the unknown metal is
displaces metal M
it is more reactive than M
above M
does not displace metal M
it is less reactive than M, or too slow to see
below M
both clues together
a bracket between two metals
the metals in between are candidates
Worked examples
Test
Result
Meaning
silver nitrate
metal displaced
X is above silver
magnesium sulfate
no reaction
X is below magnesium
candidates
zinc, iron or copper
Unknown metal X was tested by a teacher. It displaced silver from silver nitrate solution but did not displace magnesium from magnesium sulfate solution. In our ten-metal series, X is below magnesium and above silver. The candidates are zinc, iron and copper.
Test
Result
Candidates left
silver nitrate
displaced
zinc, iron, copper
magnesium sulfate
no reaction
zinc, iron, copper
copper chloride
displaced
zinc, iron
A third test narrows the list down. X is added to copper chloride solution and a pink-brown coating forms on it. X is above copper, so it cannot be copper. Zinc and iron are left, and one more test, with iron sulfate solution, would decide between them.
Metal
Above copper?
Safe in water?
Verdict
magnesium
yes
yes
works, but costs more
iron (scrap)
yes
yes
best choice
sodium
yes
no, reacts violently
unsafe
silver
no
yes
cannot displace copper
A mine wants to recover copper from waste water that contains copper sulfate. Which metal should it add? It must be above copper, safe in water, and cheap.
Class activity
Twenty questions on the series. Write the metals potassium, sodium, lithium, calcium, magnesium, zinc, iron, copper, silver and gold on ten cards and lay them in order on the table. An adult secretly picks one card from the middle eight (not potassium or gold) and puts it face down. You may ask only questions of the kind ‘Does it displace [metal] from its compound?’, and the adult answers yes or no using the order of the cards. Count the questions you need. Then play again and try to find a plan that always needs three questions or fewer: ask about a metal in the middle of the remaining cards each time. Why does that plan work better than asking about the top card? This is a paper model of the rule only. In real tests a slow reaction can look like ‘no reaction’.
Practice
1
Metal R displaces copper from copper nitrate and silver from silver nitrate, but it does not displace zinc from zinc chloride. Use the ten-metal series to name R, and say what the ‘does not displace zinc’ clue adds.
Compound in solution
R added
copper nitrate
displaces copper
silver nitrate
displaces silver
zinc chloride
no reaction
R is iron. The first two clues say R is above copper, so R could be iron, zinc, magnesium or any metal higher up. The clue about zinc shows R is below zinc, which leaves only iron.
2
A school science store wants to recover silver from waste silver nitrate solution. Which of zinc, gold, sodium and copper could be used? Give a reason for each one you reject.
Zinc and copper could be used, since both are above silver and safe in water. Gold is below silver, so it cannot displace it. Sodium is above silver but reacts violently with water.
3
A strip of metal has lost its label. It is magnesium, zinc or silver. Draw a two-step key that uses displacement tests (done by a teacher) to name it, and say what each result means.
Candidate
Zinc sulfate
Copper sulfate
magnesium
?
?
zinc
?
?
silver
?
?
Step 1: put it in zinc sulfate solution. If zinc is displaced, it is magnesium. If not, go to step 2: put it in copper sulfate solution. If copper is displaced, it is zinc. If not, it is silver.
4
A pupil says, ‘My metal did not displace zinc, so it must be very unreactive.’ Explain why this conclusion goes too far.
The result only shows the metal is below zinc. It could be iron, copper or others, which are quite different in reactivity. It could also be a slow reaction that was not seen in the time given.