GoalDescribe the steps of natural selection and use them to explain how a population changes over generations.
New words
competition · the struggle between organisms for the same limited resources, such as food, water, light or spaceadvantageous feature · an inherited feature that gives an individual a better chance of surviving and reproducingnatural selection · the process in which individuals with advantageous features survive and reproduce more, so these features become more commongeneration · all the individuals of a population born at about the same time; the offspring are the next generation
Explanation
Natural selection explains how a species can change over many generations, with no one planning it. It has five steps. First, there is variation: individuals of a species have different features, and many of these differences are inherited because they depend on genes. Second, more young are born than can survive, so there is competition for food, water, light or space, and some are caught by predators or killed by disease or harsh weather. Third, individuals with an advantageous feature are more likely to survive and reproduce. Fourth, they pass on the genes for that feature to their offspring. Fifth, after many generations, the genes for the advantageous feature are found in more and more of the population. Look at what does not happen. An individual does not change itself because it needs to. The population changes, because some inherited features are passed on more often than others. ‘Fittest’ means best matched to the environment, not the strongest.
variation: individuals have different inherited features→more young are born than can survive: competition→individuals with an advantageous feature are more likely to survive and reproduce→they pass on their genes for that feature→over many generations the feature becomes more common
Worked examples
Stage
What happens
variation
some finches have deeper, stronger beaks and some have shallower beaks
a change and competition
the drought leaves only hard seeds; there is not enough food for all
survival
finches with deeper beaks can crack the hard seeds; more of them survive and breed
inheritance
the chicks inherit deeper beaks
result
the average beak depth in the next generation is a little greater
A real example. On a small island, a drought killed most of the soft seeds that birds called finches eat. The hard, large seeds were left. Beak depth varies in finches, and it is inherited.
Deep beaks
Shallow beaks
Share with deep beaks
before the drought
50
50
50%
survive the drought
40
10
80% of the survivors
chicks in the next generation
80
20
80%
Imaginary numbers to show how the population changes. Suppose each surviving bird has 2 chicks and the chicks have the same beak type as the parent.
A mistaken idea
A better idea
Birds grew deeper beaks because they needed them.
Some birds already had deeper beaks; they survived and passed them on.
Each bird changes during its life to fit.
The population changes from generation to generation.
The strongest always wins.
The individuals best matched to the environment leave most offspring.
Mistaken ideas, and the better ideas that replace them.
Class activity
Beak model. With an adult. You are a ‘bird’ and your beak is a kitchen tool. You need two bowls, one with dry rice (small seeds) and one with dried beans (large seeds), an empty cup, a clothes peg, a spoon and kitchen tongs or tweezers (not sharp). Use one tool at a time, moving seeds one by one into the cup for 15 seconds, with the same hand. Do the test 3 times for each tool and each food, and write the counts in a table. Predict first: which tool is best for each food? Find the mean for each. Now suppose a drought leaves only the large seeds: which ‘beak’ would survive and have chicks? What does the model leave out (think of genes and the passing on of beaks)? Do not eat the food, and wash your hands.
Practice
1
These sentences about grass beside a salted road are jumbled: A The seeds of the survivors grow into plants that are mostly salt-tolerant. B Plants that tolerate salt survive and make seeds. C Grass plants vary in how well they cope with salt. D Many plants die. E After many years most of the grass is salt-tolerant. Put them in order.
Letter
Sentence
A
The seeds of the survivors grow into plants that are mostly salt-tolerant.
B
Plants that tolerate salt survive and make seeds.
C
Grass plants vary in how well they cope with salt.
D
Many plants die.
E
After many years most of the grass is salt-tolerant.
C, D, B, A, E.
2
A pupil writes: ‘The finches grew deeper beaks because they needed to crack the seeds.’ Explain what is wrong, and write a better sentence.
Individuals do not change their beaks because they need to. Better: finches vary in beak depth, the ones with deeper beaks survived and had chicks, and they passed on the genes for deeper beaks.
3
Desert beetles collect drinking water from fog on their backs. A beetle needs at least 3 drops a day to survive. Which beetles survive, and what do you expect in the next generation if bumpy backs are inherited?
Beetle
Back
Drops of water collected per day
A
slightly bumpy
3
B
very bumpy
5
C
smooth
1
A and B survive (3 and 5 drops). C does not (1 drop). The next generation will have more beetles with bumpy backs.
4
Explain why natural selection can only change features that are inherited, and give one feature that is not.
A feature only builds up over generations if the genes for it are passed on. Features gained during life, such as a scar, are not in the genes of the gametes, so they are not passed on.