GoalExplain what variation is, tell discontinuous from continuous variation, and choose the right graph for each kind of data.
New words
variation · the differences between individuals of the same speciesspecies · a group of living things of the same kind that can breed together and have fertile offspringdiscontinuous variation · a feature that falls into separate categories, with nothing in betweencontinuous variation · a feature that can have any value in a range, usually measured
Explanation
Look at ten sunflowers in a field: no two are exactly alike. Variation means the differences between individuals of the same species. A cat and a dog differ because they are different species, so that is not variation in this sense. Some features show discontinuous variation. They fall into clear categories, and nothing lies between, for example whether a person’s earlobes are attached or free, or whether a snail’s shell is yellow, pink or brown. You record these by counting how many are in each category, and show them in a bar chart, with a gap between the bars. Other features show continuous variation. They can take any value in a range, such as height, length of a leaf or mass of an egg. Most individuals are near the middle of the range and few are at the ends. You record these by measuring, and show them in a frequency diagram, whose bars touch. Variation has causes in the genes and in the environment, as the third lesson shows.
Discontinuous variation
Continuous variation
the feature
separate categories
any value in a range
how recorded
counting each category
measuring
graph
bar chart: bars apart, categories on the x-axis
frequency diagram: bars touching, groups of values on the x-axis
example
colour of a snail’s shell
length of a sunflower seed
Worked examples
Feature
Kind of variation
Reason
earlobes attached or free
discontinuous
only two categories
mass of a hen’s egg
continuous
any mass in a range
colour of a snail’s shell: yellow, pink or brown
discontinuous
three separate categories
length of a sunflower seed
continuous
measured, any value in a range
Which kind of variation? Use the test: can you measure it and get any value, or must it fall in one of a few boxes?
A bar chart for category data. A student found 80 snails in a hedge and sorted them by the colour of the shell: 38 yellow, 24 pink and 18 brown. The bars are apart because the categories are separate, and the order of the categories does not matter.
Comparison
Variation within a species?
two daisies, one with 21 petals and one with 34
yes
a daisy and a dandelion
no: two different species
a large and a small dog of one breed
yes
a cat and a dog
no: two different species
Not variation within a species. Comparing a snail with a slug, or a daisy with a dandelion, shows differences between species. Variation is about individuals of the same species.
Class activity
Survey and measure. With an adult. Part A: with their permission, look at the earlobes of 15 people at home or school (attached or free); write the counts but not the names, and draw a bar chart. Part B: with an adult’s help choose one bush or tree that is safe to touch, and pick 10 leaves of the same kind from it (wash your hands afterwards). Measure each leaf from base to tip, to the nearest mm. Predict: which of the two sets of data can you put into a few boxes? Which one has values everywhere between the smallest and the largest? Say which is discontinuous and which is continuous, and what graph each needs.
Practice
1
Which of these pairs show variation within one species? A two ladybirds of one species, one with 2 spots and one with 7. B a cat and a dog. C two sunflowers, one 1.2 m tall and one 1.9 m tall. D a tree and a blade of grass.
Letter
Pair
A
two ladybirds of one species, with 2 and 7 spots
B
a cat and a dog
C
two sunflowers, 1.2 m and 1.9 m tall
D
a tree and a blade of grass
A and C. B and D compare different species.
2
State whether each feature shows continuous or discontinuous variation: (a) colour of sweet-pea flowers (white, pink, purple), (b) length of a cat’s tail, (c) mass of a tomato, (d) whether a rose has thorns.
A shelter has 30 cats with these coat colours. Say how you would draw the graph (what goes on each axis, and whether the bars touch). Which colour is the most common?
Coat
Number of cats
black
9
ginger
5
tabby
11
white
5
A bar chart: colours on the x-axis, number of cats on the y-axis, with gaps between the bars. Tabby is the most common (11).
4
A student draws a bar chart of flower colour with the bars touching. What should she change, and why?
Leave gaps between the bars. Flower colour is in separate categories, and touching bars are for measurements that run on from one group to the next.