GoalCompare rate graphs for different concentrations, and explain both the starting slope and the final amount.
New words
initial rate · the rate at the very start, when the most reactant is presentstrength (here) · how concentrated the acid solution is, as a percentage of the full-strength solutionexcess solid · more solid than the acid can react with, so the acid limits the reactionproportional · changing by the same factor: double one and the other doubles
Explanation
A teacher reacts 25 cm³ of a weak acid solution with plenty of baking soda, using three strengths of acid made by dilution: 100%, 50% and 25%. The solid is in excess, so the acid is the limiting reactant. Each time the concentration is halved, the line starts about half as steep, because there are half as many acid particles in each cm³ and the collisions are half as frequent. Each time the concentration is halved, the final volume is also halved, because there is half as much acid. All three lines flatten when the acid has been used up, and the weakest one flattens sooner. In a fair test the volume of acid, the mass of baking soda, the temperature and the way of measuring the gas stay the same.
Worked examples
Time (s)
100% acid (cm³)
50% acid (cm³)
25% acid (cm³)
0
0
0
0
30
26
14
7
60
40
21
11
90
48
25
13
120
52
27
14
150
54
28
14
180
55
28
14
210
56
28
14
240
56
28
14
The results in a table. Each column is one run.
Acid strength
Gas in the first 30 s (cm³)
Average rate, 0–30 s (cm³/s)
Final gas (cm³)
100%
26
0.87
56
50%
14
0.47
28
25%
7
0.23
14
Working out the starting rates and comparing. In the first 30 s, 26 cm³ of gas was made from 100% acid, so the average rate is 26 ÷ 30 = 0.87 cm³/s. The values for 50% and 25% are 14 ÷ 30 = 0.47 and 7 ÷ 30 = 0.23 cm³/s. Halving the concentration roughly halves the starting rate.
Strength compared with 25%
Final gas compared with 25% (cm³)
×1 (25%)
14
×2 (50%)
28
×4 (100%)
56
The final volumes show the limiting reactant at work: 28 is twice 14, and 56 is twice 28.
Class activity
Balloon test again. With an adult, outdoors or over a tray; eye care. You need 3 identical bottles of 500 mL, 3 balloons from the same pack, white vinegar, water, a measuring jug, baking soda, a funnel, string, a ruler and a timer. In bottle 1 put 40 mL of vinegar. In bottle 2 put 20 mL of vinegar and 20 mL of water. In bottle 3 put 10 mL of vinegar and 30 mL of water. The adult puts 1 level teaspoon of baking soda in each balloon and fits the balloons on the bottles. Do one bottle at a time: lift the balloon so the soda falls in, start the timer, and measure the circumference of the balloon at 30 seconds. Then wait until the fizzing stops and measure again. Predict first. Record in a table. Which measurement tells you about the rate and which about the amount? Name one thing that makes the method not very exact (think of the balloons). Never close a bottle with a lid, and do not drink anything.
Practice
1
Three runs used the same solid in excess and the same volume of acid at different concentrations. Match the runs to acids of 90%, 60% and 30%, and explain how you know.
Run
Gas after 30 s (cm³)
Final gas (cm³)
P
24
54
Q
16
36
R
8
18
P is 90%, Q is 60% and R is 30%. The first 30 s gas (24, 16, 8) and the final volumes (54, 36, 18) are both in the ratio 3 : 2 : 1, as the concentrations are.
2
A pupil compares 25 cm³ of 100% acid with 50 cm³ of 50% acid, both with plenty of solid. Which has the higher starting rate, and how do the final volumes compare?
The 25 cm³ of 100% acid has the higher starting rate, because its concentration is higher. The 50 cm³ of 50% acid contains the same amount of acid particles in total (50 × 50 = 25 × 100), so both give the same final volume.
3
Show how to make 100 cm³ of a 10 g/dm³ solution from a 40 g/dm³ stock.
A quarter of the strength is needed, so 25 cm³ of stock plus 75 cm³ of water. Check: 40 × 0.025 = 1 g in 0.1 dm³ = 10 g/dm³.
4
Use collision ideas to explain why 25% acid gives a lower starting rate and a lower final volume than 100% acid.
There are fewer acid particles in each cm³, so collisions with the solid are less frequent and the rate is lower. There is also less acid in total, so it runs out sooner, and a smaller amount of gas is made.