GoalPlan a fair and safe investigation of temperature, spot the faults in a plan, and explain the results with collisions.
New words
control variable · something kept the same so that the test is fairrange · the lowest and highest values of the variable you changereliable · gives about the same result when it is repeatedconclusion · a statement of what the results show, that matches the evidence
Explanation
A good plan has a question, a prediction with a reason, the variable to change, the variable to measure, the variables to control, the equipment, a safety note, a results table and a number of repeats. For temperature, choose a range and equal steps, for example 5 °C to 45 °C in steps of 10 °C. Measure the temperature at the start of each run. Keep the same type and size of tablet, the volume of water and the cup, and have the same person judge when the fizzing stops. At home an adult prepares the water, which must never be hot, and a child only reads the thermometer. Hotter water is for the teacher’s water bath. After the results you can write a conclusion: ‘As the temperature rises, the time falls, so the rate rises.’ The explanation is that the particles move faster, collide more often, and more of the collisions have enough energy. Then evaluate: temperature changes a little during a run, the end point is judged by eye, and only one kind of tablet was used.
Part of the plan
For the tablet investigation
question
Does the temperature of the water change the time a tablet takes to stop fizzing?
change (independent variable)
water temperature: 5 °C, 15 °C, 25 °C, 35 °C, 45 °C
measure (dependent variable)
time from adding the tablet until the fizzing stops (s)
keep the same (control variables)
type and size of tablet, 150 mL of water, the cup, who judges the end
safety
water never hotter than comfortably warm; an adult prepares it
reliability
three runs at each temperature; a mean; an anomalous result checked
Worked examples
What the plan says
Problem
Better
cold, warm and kettle-hot water
hot water can scald; only three temperatures
adult prepares water from 5 °C to 45 °C, five equal steps
a big tablet in the cold cup, a small piece in the hot cup
the size of the tablet changes too
the same whole tablet every time
different amounts of water
volume is not controlled
150 mL in each, measured with a jug
‘stop when it is about done’
the end point is vague
stop when the fizzing stops, judged by the same person
each temperature tried once
an anomaly could not be spotted
three runs and a mean
Aisha’s first plan has five weaknesses. Each one makes the results unfair or unsafe.
Cold and enzymes. Browning of a cut apple is a chemical reaction of the apple’s substances with oxygen from the air, helped by enzymes. A fridge is cold, so the browning is much slower there. The reaction still goes on, only more slowly.
Water temperature (°C)
Run 1 (s)
Run 2 (s)
Run 3 (s)
Mean time (s)
Rate = 1000 ÷ time
5
15
25
35
45
A results table drawn before the test, with units in the headings, ready for the readings. Rate is worked out later as 1000 ÷ the mean time.
Class activity
Apple test. With an adult. You need a fresh apple that an adult cuts into 4 equal slices, 2 identical small plates, a fridge, a clock, and a pencil. Put 2 slices on one plate in the kitchen (about 20 °C, out of strong sunlight) and 2 slices on the other plate inside the fridge. At the start, after 1 hour and after 3 hours, look at each plate and give the browning a score from 0 (white) to 5 (very brown). Predict first. Record the scores in a table and decide what to keep the same: the apple, the size of the slices, and whether the slices are covered. Do not eat the test slices. What is the independent variable? What is the dependent variable? Name one thing that makes the result less reliable.
Practice
1
Plan a test of how the temperature of water affects how fast a sugar cube dissolves, using the headings: change, measure, keep the same, safety.
Change: the water temperature (for example 5, 15, 25, 35, 45 °C, prepared by an adult and never hotter than comfortably warm). Measure: the time until no sugar can be seen. Keep the same: size of cube, volume of water, the cup, the stirring, who judges. Safety: an adult prepares the water, and the child only reads the thermometer.
2
A pupil tests 5 °C, 10 °C, 15 °C, 80 °C and 90 °C. Explain why this range is not well chosen.
The values are not spread evenly: there is a gap between 15 °C and 80 °C where nothing is known, so the pattern cannot be seen. The 80–90 °C water is also dangerously hot for a child to use. Equal steps from 5 °C to 45 °C are better.
3
Explain, using the ideas of collisions and energy, why the tablet at 45 °C stops fizzing in a much shorter time than the one at 5 °C.
At 45 °C the particles move faster and collide more often, and a much larger share of the collisions have enough energy to react. More successful collisions in each second means a faster reaction, so the reactants are used up sooner.
4
A pupil writes the conclusion: ‘Temperature makes reactions go faster, so a reaction at 200 °C is 1000 times faster.’ Say what is wrong with it.
The evidence covers only the range tested, 5 °C to 45 °C, so the conclusion cannot reach 200 °C. The doubling rule is only a rough guide, and at very high temperatures other things happen.