GoalTurn times from a temperature test into rates, handle repeats and an anomalous result, and describe the pattern on a graph.
New words
independent variable · the variable you change on purposedependent variable · the variable you measure to see the effectmean · the sum of the values divided by how many there aretrend · the general pattern in the results
Explanation
In a temperature test, the temperature is the independent variable, and the time for the reaction is the dependent variable. A short time means a fast reaction, so the rate goes up when the time goes down. A simple measure of rate is 1 ÷ time. Here the rate is given as 1000 ÷ time to give easier numbers. A good test repeats each temperature at least three times and finds the mean. A result that is far from the others, such as 55 s among 40 s and 42 s, is anomalous. It is usually left out of the mean, and you should say so and, if you can, find the cause. On a graph of time against temperature the line falls steeply and then flattens. On a graph of rate against temperature the line rises faster and faster. Both show the same trend: the higher the temperature, the faster the reaction. A conclusion must match the evidence: it can say what happened in the range tested, but not what happens far outside it.
Worked examples
Water temperature (°C)
Run 1 (s)
Run 2 (s)
Run 3 (s)
Mean time (s)
Rate = 1000 ÷ time
5
305
312
313
310
3.2
15
158
161
161
160
6.3
25
81
83
82
82
12.2
35
40
42
55
41
24.4
45
20
21
22
21
47.6
Results of a teacher’s test with a tablet in 150 mL of water in a water bath. At 35 °C, run 3 (55 s) is far from the others (40 s and 42 s), so the mean is taken from the first two: (40 + 42) ÷ 2 = 41 s. The other means use all three runs. Rate is 1000 ÷ time.
The same results as a graph of rate against temperature. The rate roughly doubles for each 10 °C: 3.2, 6.3, 12.2, 24.4, 47.6. The graph curves upwards.
A different pair of runs with a gas syringe: the same amounts of reactants at 20 °C and 30 °C. The warmer run is steeper and finishes sooner, but both end at 56 cm³, because the temperature does not change the amount of limiting reactant.
Class activity
Warm and cold tablets. With an adult. You need three identical clear cups, 150 mL of water in each, a thermometer, a timer and three identical whole effervescent tablets kept just for this (not to be eaten or drunk). The adult prepares one cup of cold water from the fridge (about 5 °C), one of room-temperature water, and one of water that feels comfortably warm from the tap, never hotter than 45 °C. You read and write down each temperature just before adding the tablet. Add one tablet at a time, start the timer, and stop it when the fizzing stops. Predict first. Record the temperature and the time, calculate 1000 ÷ time, and draw a graph. The temperature of the water changes a little during the test: say why that matters. Repeat another day. Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
At 20 °C a reaction takes 100 s and at 40 °C it takes 25 s. How many times faster is the second? Does this fit the doubling rule?
100 ÷ 25 = 4 times faster. A 20 °C rise is two steps of 10 °C, and 2 × 2 = 4, so it fits the rule.
2
Find the mean time at each temperature, leaving out any anomalous result.
Water temperature (°C)
Run 1 (s)
Run 2 (s)
Run 3 (s)
10
220
224
218
30
60
95
62
At 10 °C: (220 + 224 + 218) ÷ 3 = 220.7 or about 221 s. At 30 °C: the 95 s run is anomalous; the mean of 60 and 62 is 61 s.
3
A pupil draws time against temperature, sees the line fall, and says: ‘the reaction slows down as it gets warmer’. What is wrong?
A shorter time means a faster reaction. The falling line shows that the rate increases as the temperature rises.
4
The pattern in the lesson’s table is that the time about halves each 10 °C. Predict the time at 55 °C, and say how far you can trust that prediction.
About 21 ÷ 2 = 10 s at 55 °C. It is a prediction outside the temperatures tested, so it is less reliable: the pattern may not keep going.