GoalExplain the effect of surface area using collisions, plan a fair test and use the idea to understand dust hazards.
New words
collision frequency · how many collisions happen in each seconddust explosion · very fast burning of a cloud of fine dust mixed with aircontrol variable · something kept the same to make a test fairprediction · a statement of what you expect to happen, with a reason
Explanation
In a reaction between a solid and a liquid, particles of the liquid can collide only with the particles at the surface of the solid. A lump has few particles at its surface compared with its total number. A powder has many more at its surface. So the same acid particles meet many more solid particles in each second, and there are more successful collisions in each second. The energy of each collision is the same, because the temperature has not changed. Only the frequency of collisions has changed. The total amount of product depends on the amount of limiting reactant, so it stays the same. This is also why fine dust, such as flour or sugar in the air of a factory, is dangerous: a cloud of dust has a huge surface area in contact with oxygen and can burn so fast that it explodes. Factories clean away dust and control sparks. To test surface area fairly, change only the size of the pieces and keep the rest the same.
Lump
Powder
surface area exposed
small
large
collisions with acid particles in each second
fewer
more
energy of each collision
same
same
rate
slower
faster
final amount of product
same
same
Worked examples
Run 1
Run 2
state of the solid
5.0 g of lumps
2.0 g of powder
acid
50 cm³ from bottle A
50 cm³ from bottle B (twice as concentrated)
temperature
20 °C
20 °C
An unfair test. In Run 2 of the table, two things differ besides the size of the pieces. A powder run in a stronger acid would be faster for two reasons, and we would not know how much was due to each.
log: small surface area, burns slowly→shavings: larger surface area, burns quickly→sawdust cloud: huge surface area, can explode
Dust and fire: a log burns slowly, wood shavings burn faster and fine sawdust in the air can explode. The same mass of wood, in smaller and smaller pieces, has a larger and larger surface area in contact with oxygen.
A graph comparing two runs of limestone with the same acid. The pieces in M are smaller than in N. Both runs end at 50 cm³, so M and N had the same amount of limestone.
Class activity
Cube counting. With an adult. You need 27 small identical building blocks (cubes of about 2 cm). First make one 2 × 2 × 2 cube from 8 blocks and count how many block faces you can see on the outside (not touching another block or the table; imagine it is floating). Then spread the 8 blocks apart and count faces again. Then build a 3 × 3 × 3 cube from 27 blocks and count the outer faces, and then separate all 27 and count. Predict first. Make a table, find how many times bigger the total is after separating, and compare with the number of blocks along one side. Keep small blocks away from small children.
Practice
1
Leo’s teacher drops an iron nail and the same mass of iron filings into two flasks of the same dilute sulfuric acid. Write the word equation, and explain why the filings react faster.
iron + sulfuric acid → iron sulfate + hydrogen (Fe + H₂SO₄ → FeSO₄ + H₂). The filings have a much larger surface area, so more iron particles are exposed to acid particles. There are more collisions in each second, more successful collisions, and a higher rate.
2
Look at the table of two runs. Which two variables were not controlled, and how should the experiment be changed?
Run 1
Run 2
state of the solid
3.0 g of chips
3.0 g of powder
volume of acid
40 cm³
60 cm³
temperature
20 °C
30 °C
The volume of acid (40 cm³ and 60 cm³) and the temperature (20 °C and 30 °C) differ. Use the same volume of acid at the same temperature in both runs, and change only chips or powder.
3
Cut a 5 cm cube of marble into 1 cm cubes: its surface area rises from 150 cm² to 750 cm². A student says: ‘So the reaction will make 5 times more product.’ Explain what is wrong.
Surface area changes the rate, not the amount. The amount of product depends on the amount of limiting reactant, which has not changed. The reaction will be about 5 times faster at the start, not make 5 times more.
4
A student finds that the powder run ended at 60 cm³ of gas, but the lump run ended at 48 cm³. Suggest two reasons that are not about surface area.
More powder than lumps may have been used (different mass), or the acid was a different volume or concentration, or some gas was lost or the syringe leaked in the lump run.