GoalCompare the rates of reactions of different-sized pieces of a solid from data, and see that the final amount stays the same.
New words
rate ยท the amount made or used per unit of timefine ยท made of very small piecesfair test ยท an investigation in which only one variable is changed and the others are kept the sametotal mass lost ยท all the mass that has left the flask as gas by a given time
Explanation
A solid reacts faster when its surface area is bigger. In a classroom test, an effervescent tablet gives off carbon dioxide when it meets water. The teacher puts the same tablet into water in a flask on a balance, whole, in halves, or crushed, and reads the mass lost every 20 seconds. The crushed tablet loses mass fastest, so its line is the steepest and flattens first. The whole tablet is the slowest. All three lines end at the same height, because the tablets have the same mass and contain the same amounts of the reactants. Surface area changes the rate but not the total amount made. In a fair test the water volume, water temperature and tablet mass are kept the same, and only the size of the pieces changes.
Worked examples
Time (s)
Crushed tablet (g)
Tablet in halves (g)
Whole tablet (g)
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
20
0.30
0.17
0.11
40
0.38
0.27
0.19
60
0.40
0.33
0.25
80
0.40
0.36
0.29
100
0.40
0.38
0.32
120
0.40
0.39
0.35
140
0.40
0.40
0.37
160
0.40
0.40
0.38
180
0.40
0.40
0.39
200
0.40
0.40
0.40
The results of the teacherโs three runs (a balance reading to 0.01 g).
Tablet
Mass lost in the first 20 s (g)
Rate in the first 20 s (g/min)
Time to reach 0.40 g (s)
crushed
0.30
0.90
60
in halves
0.17
0.51
140
whole
0.11
0.33
200
Working out the rate. In the first 20 s the crushed tablet lost 0.30 g, which is 0.30 รท 20 = 0.015 g/s or 0.9 g/min. The whole tablet lost 0.11 g, or 0.33 g/min. The crushed tablet reacted about 2.7 times faster at the start. Each run needs a different time to reach the final 0.40 g.
Two bar charts of the same data: in the first 20 s the amount of carbon dioxide lost is very different, but at the end it is the same.
Class activity
Three cups. With an adult. You need three identical clear cups with 150 mL of cool tap water, three identical effervescent tablets kept just for this (not to be eaten or drunk), a bag and spoon, and a timer. The adult makes sure the water in the cups is the same temperature. Prepare tablet A whole, tablet B broken into four pieces, and tablet C crushed to powder in the bag. Add one tablet at a time, start the timer, and stop it when the fizzing stops and the water looks still. Record the times in a table, and predict first. Repeat on another day and find the mean. Keep the same: the type of tablet, the volume and temperature of the water. Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Use the table. How many times faster is the powder than the whole tablet, if the rate is proportional to 1 รท time? Which step, from one column to the next, saves the most time?
Pieces
Whole
Broken in 2
Broken in 4
Powder
Time until fizzing stops (s)
180
100
60
25
180 รท 25 = 7.2, so about 7 times faster. The steps save 80 s, 40 s and 35 s, so the biggest saving is from whole to broken in 2.
2
In a similar test, a whole tablet lost 0.14 g in 20 s and a crushed one lost 0.36 g. Give each average rate in g/min.
Explain why the three lines in the graph end at the same height.
The tablets had the same mass, so they contained the same amount of limiting reactant. Changing the size of the pieces changes how fast the product is made, not how much is made.
4
Sketch (or describe) the line for a tablet broken into four pieces, if the halves line is already drawn. Where does it start, how steep is it compared with the others, and where does it end?
It starts at 0, and is steeper than the line for halves but less steep than the crushed line. It ends at the same 0.40 g, reached between 60 s and 140 s.