GoalUse collision theory to explain why a reaction slows down, and judge how well a rate has been measured.
New words
collision theory · particles react only when they collide, and only if the collision has enough energysuccessful collision · a collision with enough energy to cause a reactionrepeat · doing the measurement again, so that a mean can be foundanomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern, often caused by a mistake
Explanation
Collision theory says that particles can react only when they collide, and only when the collision has enough energy. So the rate depends on how often particles collide and on how many of the collisions are successful. At the start there are many reactant particles, so there are many collisions in each second and the rate is high. As the reactants are used up there are fewer of them, the collisions become less frequent, and the rate falls. When one reactant has gone, that reaction cannot go on, and the graph is flat. Measuring takes care too. The gas can escape before the bung is in, the timer can be started late, some carbon dioxide dissolves in water, and a balance may not show a small loss. Repeating a measurement three times and finding the mean makes the result more reliable, and an anomalous result can be left out if you say so.
Worked examples
Element
Atoms on the left
Atoms on the right
Ca
1 (CaCO₃)
1 (CaCl₂)
C
1 (CaCO₃)
1 (CO₂)
O
3 (in CaCO₃)
3 (1 in H₂O + 2 in CO₂)
H
2 (2HCl)
2 (H₂O)
Cl
2 (2HCl)
2 (CaCl₂)
Teacher demonstration: lumps of limestone (calcium carbonate) in dilute hydrochloric acid in a flask on a balance, with a loose cotton wool plug to stop spray. CaCO₃ + 2HCl → CaCl₂ + H₂O + CO₂. The atoms are all still there, so the equation balances. The flask loses mass only because the carbon dioxide escapes.
Run
Gas after 60 s (cm³)
1
49
2
52
3
61
Repeats. Three runs gave these volumes after 60 s. Runs 1 and 2 are close and run 3 is far from them, so run 3 is probably anomalous. The mean of runs 1 and 2 is (49 + 52) ÷ 2 = 50.5 cm³. With run 3, the mean (54) would be pulled up. If a cause cannot be found, repeat again rather than just delete a value.
Problem
Effect on the results
Better way
gas escapes while the bung is pushed in
volume too low at every time
fit the bung first and tip the flask to mix, or start the timer at once
the timer is started late
all the times are too short
start the timer at the moment of mixing
carbon dioxide dissolves a little in water over which it is collected
volume too low
use a gas syringe
the balance reading drifts in a draught
mass lost looks wrong
shield the balance and use a lid or cotton wool plug
Sources of error and how to reduce them.
Class activity
Fizz fade. With an adult. You need a clear glass with 200 mL of cool tap water, an effervescent tablet kept just for this (not to be eaten or drunk), and a timer. The adult drops the tablet in and you keep your face back. Every 10 seconds for 60 seconds, give the fizzing a score from 0 (none) to 5 (very strong) and write it in the table. Draw a bar chart. Predict first: which 10 seconds will score highest? Then evaluate: you gave the scores by eye, so how could another person get a different answer? Suggest one change, such as filming the glass and counting, or timing how long until the fizzing stops, to make the measuring better. Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Explain, using collisions, why the rate of a reaction in a flask falls as time goes on.
Reactant particles are used up, so there are fewer of them in the same space. Collisions between them happen less often, so fewer successful collisions occur each second and the rate falls.
2
Four runs of an experiment gave these volumes. Which is anomalous? Find the mean of the others and suggest one possible cause.
Run
Gas after 90 s (cm³)
1
31
2
33
3
32
4
24
24 cm³ is anomalous. The mean of 31, 33 and 32 is 96 ÷ 3 = 32 cm³. A cause: gas escaped before the bung was in, or the timer was started late.
3
In the limestone demonstration, the balance shows a mass 1.1 g lower at the end. Where has the mass gone, and has the law of conservation of mass been broken?
The carbon dioxide gas escaped through the open top of the flask. The law is not broken: if the gas could not escape (only imagine this; a sealed flask is not safe), the reading would stay the same.
4
Choose the best way to follow each reaction: the balance, a gas syringe, or a stopwatch.
Reaction
What happens
A
a solid fizzes in an open flask and a heavy gas escapes
B
a flask joined by a tube to a syringe makes hydrogen, which is very light
C
a clear liquid slowly turns cloudy
A: the balance, because a heavy gas escapes (a gas syringe would also work). B: a gas syringe, because hydrogen is too light for the balance. C: a stopwatch, timing how long until the cloudiness is seen.