GoalCompare the collision, fission and capture hypotheses, explain how scientists test them and describe the open questions.
New words
fission hypothesis · the idea that the Moon is a piece thrown off a fast-spinning young Earthcapture hypothesis · the idea that the Moon formed elsewhere and was caught by the Earth’s gravitysimulation · a computer model that follows what would happen over timeopen question · something scientists have not yet explained
Explanation
There are three main ideas for the Moon’s origin. In the fission hypothesis the Moon is a piece of the Earth thrown off while it spun fast. In the capture hypothesis the Moon formed elsewhere and was caught by the Earth’s gravity. In the collision hypothesis a crash produced the debris. A body that formed far away would be expected to have different rocks from the Earth’s, and a large fast object usually flies past unless something slows it down, so capture has difficulties. Fission would give similar rocks, but scientists have found it hard to make a spinning Earth throw off a piece that ends up in orbit. Computer simulations try different sizes, speeds and angles for an impact and compare the results with the real Moon. At present the collision hypothesis fits the most evidence, but it is still tested. Open questions, such as why the rocks are so alike, keep scientists working.
Hypothesis
The idea
Rocks like Earth’s?
Main difficulty
fission
a piece of a fast-spinning Earth
yes
hard to make a piece go into orbit
capture
formed elsewhere, then caught
probably not
a big fast object is hard to catch
collision
debris from an impact
yes, if from the outer layers
rocks may be too alike; details unclear
Worked examples
Clue
Fission
Capture
Collision
Moon rocks are like Earth’s outer layers
fits
does not fit well
fits
the Moon has a small iron core
fits
not expected
fits well
the Moon is made of rock
fits
fits
fits
Which idea does each clue support? A clue that fits every idea cannot help us to choose.
choose the size, speed and angle of the impact→the computer follows the heating and movement of the rock→compare with the real Moon: size, orbit, makeup→keep, change or reject that version
How a simulation works as a test.
Too strong
Better
The Moon was made by a crash.
Scientists think the Moon was made by a crash.
The rocks prove it.
The rocks support the hypothesis.
Other ideas are stupid.
Other ideas fit less of the evidence.
Choosing words that match the evidence.
Class activity
Evidence detectives. On paper draw three columns: fission, capture, collision. Write these clues on small cards: 1, the Moon’s rocks are like the Earth’s outer layers; 2, the Moon has a small iron core; 3, the Moon is about a quarter of the Earth’s width; 4, the Moon orbits the Earth; 5, the Moon has many craters. Put each card under every idea it fits, then count the cards in each column. Which clues fit all three ideas, and do they help to choose between them? (Adult: clues 4 and 5 fit every idea, so they cannot help to choose.) Which idea has the most clues that fit well? Write one sentence about what your table shows and one about what it cannot show.
Practice
1
Someone says: ‘The collision idea is only a theory, so it is just a guess.’ Explain why that is a poor way to describe a scientific hypothesis supported by evidence.
A scientific hypothesis is an explanation that has been tested against evidence. This one fits several independent clues, so it is much more than a guess, although it can still change if new evidence appears.
2
A new Moon rock is found that is very different from the Earth’s rocks. Which of the three hypotheses would this clue help most, and does it prove that hypothesis? Explain.
It would help the capture hypothesis, because a body that formed far away should have different rocks. It would not prove it: evidence supports an idea but does not prove it, and scientists would then test whether versions of the collision idea can explain the difference.
3
A scientist ran four computer simulations of an impact (invented data). Which pair shows the effect of the size of the object, and which pair shows the effect of its speed? Which run could make a Moon like ours?
Run
Object
Speed (km/s)
Debris in orbit (Moon masses)
A
much smaller than Mars
10
0.2
B
Mars-sized
10
1.6
C
Mars-sized
15
0.8
D
much smaller than Mars
15
0.4
Runs A and B (same speed, different size) show the effect of size, and runs B and C (same size, different speed) show the effect of speed. Only run B puts at least one Moon’s mass of debris into orbit.
4
Name one open question about the Moon’s formation, and say how scientists might try to answer it.
For example: why Moon and Earth rocks are so alike. Scientists could test new versions in simulations, or study more rock samples and compare them with predictions.