GoalUse evidence from Moon rocks, density and size to judge how well it supports the collision hypothesis.
New words
evidence · observations and measurements used to support or reject an ideaprediction · what we expect to find if a hypothesis is correctcore · the dense centre of a planet or moon, made mainly of ironsample · a piece of material collected for study
Explanation
A good hypothesis makes predictions that can be checked. Scientists think the iron of the young Earth had already sunk to form its core before the impact, so the debris came mainly from rocky outer layers. Prediction 1: the Moon should be made of rock much like the Earth’s outer layers. Prediction 2: it should contain little iron, so its average density should be low and its core small. Samples brought back by space missions are similar in many ways to rocks from the Earth’s mantle. The Moon’s average density is about 3.3 g/cm³, compared with about 5.5 g/cm³ for the Earth, and measurements suggest a small iron core. The Moon is also large compared with the Earth, which suggests that an unusual event was needed. There are open questions: the rocks are so alike that scientists expected more difference, so new versions of the hypothesis are being tested. Evidence can support an idea, but it never proves it.
Prediction of the collision hypothesis
What scientists have found
Supports it?
rock like the Earth’s outer layers
Moon samples are similar in many ways
yes
little iron, so low density
about 3.3 g/cm³ against about 5.5 g/cm³ for Earth
yes
a big event was needed
the Moon is about a quarter of the Earth’s width
fits
some difference from Earth’s rocks
rocks are very alike
open question
Worked examples
Material
Density (g/cm³)
rock (about)
3
iron (about)
8
mixture of equal volumes
5.5
A simple model of density. Suppose rock has a density of about 3 g/cm³ and iron about 8 g/cm³. A ball made of 1 cm³ of rock and 1 cm³ of iron has a mass of 3 + 8 = 11 g and a volume of 2 cm³, so its density is 11 ÷ 2 = 5.5 g/cm³. More iron gives a higher density. A ball that is mostly rock has a density close to 3. The model is rough, because pressure inside the Earth squeezes its material, but it shows why a low density points to little iron.
Planet
Width of planet (km)
Width of largest moon (km)
Moon as a fraction of planet
Mars
about 6800
about 22
less than 1%
Earth
about 12 700
about 3500
more than a quarter
Why size matters. Mars has two tiny moons, the biggest about 22 km across, which is less than 1% of the width of Mars. Our Moon is about 3500 km across, more than a quarter of the width of the Earth. A Moon that large needs a special explanation.
an observation does not fit the first version→scientists change a detail and test again→a new version fits more of the evidence
An observation that does not fit neatly. If much of the debris came from the other object, which formed elsewhere, the Moon’s rocks might be expected to differ from the Earth’s more than they do. Scientists do not throw the hypothesis away; they test versions in which more material comes from the Earth or the two bodies mix more.
Class activity
A dense core, or not? With an adult. Take two identical clear jars or cups. Fill jar A to a marked line with flour only. In jar B put a layer of table salt or sugar about 2 cm deep in the bottom, then fill to the same line with flour. Level both with a ruler edge. Predict which jar will be heavier. Weigh each jar with kitchen scales (subtract the empty jar’s mass) and record the masses in a table. Keep the volume, the jar and the scales the same. Which jar is a model of a body with a dense core, and which is like the Moon? Repeat the weighing and decide whether the two readings agree. What is one limit of this model?
Practice
1
A model body has a density of 3.3 g/cm³ and a volume of 100 cm³. A second model body has the same volume and a density of 5.5 g/cm³. Work out the mass of each, and say which one contains more iron.
Body
Density (g/cm³)
Volume (cm³)
first
3.3
100
second
5.5
100
The first has a mass of 3.3 × 100 = 330 g. The second has a mass of 5.5 × 100 = 550 g. The second contains more iron, because iron is denser than rock.
2
Scientists predict that, if the Moon formed from the Earth’s outer layers, it should have little iron. Explain the reasoning.
Scientists think that most of the Earth’s iron had sunk into its core before the impact. Debris thrown out of the outer layers would contain little iron, so the Moon would have a small core and a low density.
3
A student says: ‘The Moon rocks are similar to the Earth’s rocks, so the collision hypothesis is proved.’ Give a better statement and explain what is wrong with the first.
Better: ‘This supports the collision hypothesis.’ Evidence can support an idea but not prove it, and other ideas (such as fission) also predict similar rocks.
4
The chart shows the average density of some bodies. Which has the least iron, and why can’t density alone show how the Moon formed? (Mars’s density is also low.)
The Moon has the lowest density, so it probably has the least iron. Mars also has a lower density than Earth but did not form in this way, so several kinds of evidence are needed, not density alone.