GoalInterpret data about carbon dioxide, sea level and ice, describe the effects of climate change and judge how good the evidence is.
New words
climate change · a long-term change in the pattern of the Earth’s weather and temperaturestrend · the general direction in which data change over timeparts per million (ppm) · a way to give a tiny concentration: 400 ppm is 0.04%evidence · measurements and observations that support or challenge an idea
Explanation
Scientists have measured carbon dioxide in the air on a Hawaiian mountain since 1958. It has climbed from about 315 ppm to over 420 ppm, and the rise is getting faster. Over the same time the Earth’s mean temperature has risen. Warming has effects: land ice melts, sea level rises because the extra water adds to the sea and warm water expands, habitats change, and extreme weather such as heatwaves, droughts and floods become more likely. The real record also wiggles up and down each year, because plants in the north take in more carbon dioxide in summer than in winter. A trend means more than a single event. One cold week is weather, whereas climate is the pattern over thirty years or more. Strong evidence comes from many places, over a long time, measured in different ways by different groups. Rising together does not prove a cause on its own, but the greenhouse effect explains why.
Worked examples
Years
Rise in carbon dioxide (ppm)
1960 to 1970
9
1970 to 1980
13
1980 to 1990
15
1990 to 2000
15
2000 to 2010
20
2010 to 2020
25
Reading the rise decade by decade. The increase in each ten years is bigger than the one before it.
Cause
Raises sea level?
Why
warmer sea water expands
yes
the same water takes up more space
glaciers and ice sheets on land melt
yes
new water flows into the sea
floating sea ice melts
hardly at all
it already pushes aside its own weight of water
Why does sea level rise? Different kinds of melting have different effects.
Evidence
Strong or weak?
Why
one very hot day in one city
weak
one place, one day, which is weather
temperature records from thousands of stations for over 100 years
strong
many places, a long time, repeated
a person remembering snowier winters
weak
not measured, and one place
Judging evidence. Better evidence covers many places and many years.
Class activity
Data detective, with an adult. Ask an adult to help you find the yearly mean (average) temperature of your town or city for the last 10 or more years from a weather website. Make a table and plot a line graph with years along the bottom. Does the graph go up, down or up and down? Mark any year that does not fit the pattern. Write one sentence for your conclusion and one sentence about a limit of the data, for example that it covers only one place and only a short time.
Practice
1
Use the table to find which gained carbon dioxide faster, 1960 to 1990 or 1990 to 2020. Show your working.
Year
Carbon dioxide (ppm)
1960
317
1990
354
2020
414
1960 to 1990: 354 − 317 = 37 ppm in 30 years, about 1.2 ppm a year. 1990 to 2020: 414 − 354 = 60 ppm in 30 years, about 2.0 ppm a year. So the later period was faster.
2
Explain why melting ice on Greenland raises sea level more than melting sea ice floating in the Arctic Ocean.
Ice on land adds new water to the sea. Floating ice already displaces its own weight of water, so when it melts the level hardly changes.
3
Tariq says, ‘It snowed heavily last week, so there is no climate change.’ Use the words weather, climate and evidence in your reply.
A week of snow is weather. Climate is the pattern over thirty years or more, so Tariq needs long-term measurements from many places, and these show a rise in mean temperature.
4
Describe one action a community or company could take, and one a family could take, to reduce carbon dioxide, and explain how each helps.
For example, a company can use wind or solar electricity, which burns no fuel; a family can walk or cycle for short journeys, so less petrol is burnt.