GoalSay whether a difference is caused by genes, by the environment or by both, and plan and judge a test that separates them.
New words
genetic variation ยท differences caused by different genes inherited from the parentsenvironmental variation ยท differences caused by the surroundings, such as light, food, water or accidentscutting ยท a piece of a plant that grows into a new plant with the same genes as its parentanomalous result ยท a result that does not fit the pattern and is probably a mistake
Explanation
Some differences are caused by genes. The colour of sweet-pea flowers, a personโs blood group and the pattern of a tabby catโs coat are examples. Other differences are caused by the environment: a plant in shade grows paler than the same kind in the sun, a suntan comes from light, and a scar from an injury. Many features, such as height or the mass of an egg, are caused by both. The genes set a range, and food, water, light and health decide where in the range an individual ends up. Not all variation is in the DNA. To separate the two causes, scientists use organisms with the same genes. Cuttings from one plant are clones, so if they grow differently in different places the cause must be the environment. To keep the test fair, change one thing and keep everything else the same, use several cuttings in each place, and compare means. Mark any anomalous result, and say why you think it is one, before you decide whether to leave it out.
Cause
Examples
genes only
flower colour in sweet peas; blood group; a tabby coat pattern
environment only
a suntan; a scar; a pale plant grown without light
both
height of a person or a plant; mass of an egg; mass of a cat
Worked examples
Cutting
Bright windowsill
Dim corner
1
38
22
2
41
25
3
44
19
4
40
23
5
12
21
mean of all five
35
22
Cuttings from one mint plant (same genes) were grown for 14 days in different places. Root length in mm. One result in the bright place is much lower than the others.
All five
Without the anomaly
mean in the bright place
35 mm
about 41 mm
mean in the dim corner
22 mm
22 mm
Dealing with the anomaly. 12 mm is far from the others (38 to 44) and the stem was bruised when cut, so it is probably an error. Without it the mean of the other four is 163 รท 4 = 40.75, about 41 mm. The conclusion is the same, but the difference in means (41 against 22) is clearer once the anomaly is left out and the reason is explained.
Experiment
Same
Different
What it shows
cuttings from one plant in sun and in shade
genes
environment
effect of the environment
seeds of two varieties in the same bed
environment
genes
effect of genes
Which cause does each experiment test? What differs is the thing under test.
Class activity
Same genes, different places. With an adult. Cut 6 stems of the same length from one mint, basil or coleus plant (the adult does the cutting). Put each in a jar with the same amount of tap water. Put three jars on a bright windowsill and three in a dim part of the same room, away from the window and out of direct sunlight. Predict which will grow longer roots. Which variable are you changing? Name three that you keep the same. After 14 days measure the longest root of each cutting to the nearest mm and find the mean for each place. Is there an anomalous result? Why is it better to use three cuttings than one? What other thing could differ between the two places besides light?
Practice
1
Say whether each difference is caused by genes, the environment, or both: (a) blood group, (b) a suntan, (c) the height of a sunflower, (d) a tabby coat, (e) a local accent.
Five geranium cuttings from one plant grew in compost and five grew in sand. Heights after 6 weeks in cm: compost 21, 23, 22, 24, 22; sand 14, 15, 16, 31, 15 (the 31 cm plant was by a lamp). Which result is anomalous? Calculate the mean height for each, leaving out the anomalous result, and say what the data show.
Compost (cm)
Sand (cm)
21
14
23
15
22
16
24
31
22
15
31 cm is anomalous. Compost: 112 รท 5 = 22.4 cm. Sand: 60 รท 4 = 15 cm. Because the cuttings have the same genes, the difference is caused by the environment (the compost).
3
A farmer says that wheat plants in one field are different heights. Give one genetic and one environmental reason.
Genetic: the plants have different versions of the genes for height. Environmental: some parts of the field have more water, light or minerals than others.
4
A student says: โThe cuttings in the window have longer roots, so light makes roots grow.โ Give two things that must be the same in both places for this to be a fair conclusion.
For example the temperature, the amount of water in the jars, the length of the stems, the kind of plant and the time. If the window is warmer as well, the cause could be heat as well as light.