GoalUse models of chromosomes and genes, say where each model works and where it fails, and use data and a code model to think about DNA.
New words
model · a way of picturing something that is hard to see; every model has limitsbase · one of four kinds of chemical unit in DNA, called A, C, G and T; the order of bases is the codesequence · the order of things one after another, such as the bases along a DNA moleculecode · a set of rules for turning one kind of symbol into another
Explanation
Chromosomes and genes cannot be seen by eye, so scientists and teachers use models. One model is a shelf of cookbooks: the shelf is the nucleus, each book is a chromosome, each recipe is a gene, and the writing is the DNA. This model shows that a gene is a small part of a chromosome and that the whole library is kept in one place. It fails in several ways. A person reads a recipe, but a cell reads a gene by itself. Also, most cells in your body hold the whole library, but each type of cell uses only some of the recipes, so a nerve cell and a muscle cell have the same genes but use different ones. The structure of DNA was worked out in the 1950s, when Rosalind Franklin and Maurice Wilkins made X-ray pictures of it and James Watson and Francis Crick built a model that fitted the evidence. Cells read DNA in groups of three bases. Since there are four bases, groups of three give 4 × 4 × 4 = 64 different groups, which is enough to code for the 20 different building blocks of proteins, whereas groups of two would give only 16.
Cookbook model
In the cell
the bookshelf
the nucleus
one book
one chromosome
one recipe
one gene
the letters and ink
the DNA code
Worked examples
Species
Chromosomes in a body cell
Genes (roughly)
fruit fly
8
14 000
roundworm
12
20 000
human
46
20 000
rice
24
37 000
Chromosome number and the number of genes are not linked. Species with a few chromosomes can have as many genes as species with many (the gene numbers are rounded).
Bases in a group
Different groups possible
Enough for 20 building blocks?
1
4
no
2
16
no
3
64
yes
Why three? With four bases A, C, G and T, the number of different groups is 4 for one base, 4 × 4 = 16 for two, and 4 × 4 × 4 = 64 for three. Cells need at least 20 groups, so one or two bases are not enough.
Idea in the model
Does the cell work like this?
a recipe is a small part of a book
yes: a gene is a small part of a chromosome
a person reads the book
no: the cell reads the gene itself
each book is different
yes, but the two chromosomes in a pair are similar, not identical
Judging a model. A good model is easy to understand and shows some true ideas, but a scientist always asks where it does not match the real thing.
Class activity
Code your name. With an adult. Use three-letter ‘words’ made from A, C, G and T as a code for letters: A = AAA, B = AAC, C = AAG, D = AAT, E = ACA, F = ACC, G = ACG, H = ACT, I = AGA, J = AGC. Write the word BADGE, then CAGE and HEAD, in code on a strip of paper, and ask someone to decode them. Then work out how many different three-letter words you can make from A, C, G and T (4 × 4 × 4), and how many you can make from two letters. Could a code with two-letter words cover the 26 letters of the alphabet? How is your code like the code in DNA, and how is it unlike it?
Practice
1
In the cookbook model, say what each of these stands for in a cell: the bookshelf, one recipe. Then give one way in which the model does not match a real cell.
The bookshelf is the nucleus and one recipe is one gene. One limit: people read recipes but a cell reads its genes itself (or: the cell holds two copies of each ‘book’).
2
A student says that the more chromosomes a species has, the more genes it has. Use the data in the picture to say whether this is true.
Species
Chromosomes
Genes (roughly)
roundworm
12
20 000
human
46
20 000
rice
24
37 000
No. Rice has fewer chromosomes (24) than the human (46) but more genes (about 37 000 against 20 000), and the roundworm has 12 chromosomes and about the same number of genes as the human.
3
A code uses groups of two bases chosen from A, C, G and T. How many different groups can it make? Is this enough for 20 different building blocks?
4 × 4 = 16 groups, which is not enough. Groups of three give 64, which is enough.
4
Why is it correct to say that a nerve cell and a muscle cell from the same person have the same genes but are different?
Both have the same complete set of DNA, but each cell uses only some of its genes, so they make different substances and become different types of cell.