GoalExplain why plants need nitrate and magnesium, and interpret and improve an investigation into plant food.
New words
mineral · a simple chemical that roots take up from the soil, dissolved in waternitrate · a mineral containing nitrogen, used to make proteins and chlorophyllmagnesium · a mineral that plants need to make chlorophylldeficiency · a shortage of something, shown by signs such as yellow leaves
Explanation
Plants make glucose from carbon dioxide and water, but they also need minerals from the soil. The roots take them up dissolved in water. Nitrate is needed to make proteins for growth and also helps to make chlorophyll. Magnesium is needed to make chlorophyll. A shortage of either one gives yellow leaves, because there is less chlorophyll, and then less photosynthesis, less glucose and slower growth. Plants do not take their food from the soil. They make their food, and the soil supplies water and the minerals to build new substances. Farmers add fertiliser to put minerals back, but too much can damage plants and wash into rivers. To test the effect, you change the amount of plant food, measure growth, keep other variables the same, and repeat. A pattern from several amounts is more convincing than one comparison.
Mineral
Used to make
Sign of a shortage
nitrate
proteins and chlorophyll
stunted growth and yellow leaves
magnesium
chlorophyll
yellow leaves, little photosynthesis
Worked examples
Lettuce seedlings were given different amounts of liquid plant food each day. Mean height after three weeks.
Claim
Supported?
Reason
some plant food helps growth
yes
every amount from 2 to 8 ml gave taller plants than none
more plant food is always better
no
16 ml gave shorter plants than none, so too much harms
8 ml is the best amount
not certain
4 ml and 8 ml are almost the same and no amounts between were tested
Which claims does the chart support? A good conclusion only claims what the data show.
Plant
What is seen
Most likely shortage
X
leaves yellow, but the plant is growing
magnesium, which affects chlorophyll
Y
small, stunted and pale
nitrate, which affects proteins and chlorophyll
Z
dark green and tall
none
Reading the signs. A gardener compares three plants in the same sun.
Class activity
Read the label, with an adult. Find a bottle or box of plant food for house plants. Copy the list of minerals into a table, find the nitrogen (nitrate) and magnesium, and write how much the label says to use and what warnings it gives. Do not open or taste it. Then look at a house plant with a pale leaf and a plant with dark green leaves: which minerals might the pale one lack, and which other things (light, water) could also be the cause? Wash your hands afterwards.
Practice
1
Which mineral does a plant need to make chlorophyll, and what do the leaves look like without it?
Magnesium (nitrate helps too). The leaves go yellow and the plant photosynthesises less.
2
A farmer adds nitrate fertiliser to field A but not to field B. Suggest how the nitrate led to the difference, and why the result might not be the same on another farm.
Field
Fertiliser
Wheat grain per hectare
A
nitrate added
5.1 tonnes
B
none
3.4 tonnes
Plants use nitrate to make proteins for growth, including grain. On another farm the soil, rainfall, light or the minerals already in the soil may differ.
3
Plant food was added to five pots. Which result looks anomalous? Suggest two causes and say what to do.
The 12 for 2 units is out of line with a rising trend. Causes: the pot got less light, was knocked over, or the plant was diseased. Repeat that amount and use the mean of repeats.
4
‘Plants take their food from the soil.’ Explain what is wrong with this idea.
Plants make their own food, glucose, in photosynthesis. The soil supplies water and minerals, which are needed to make other substances but are not the food itself.