GoalUse conservation of mass to find unknown masses, explain why some reactions seem to gain or lose mass, and deal with unexpected results.
New words
conservation of mass · the total mass of the products equals the total mass of the reactantsclosed system · a container from which nothing can escape and into which nothing can enteranomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern of the othersmean · the average: the total of the values divided by how many there are
Explanation
Atoms are not lost in a reaction, so the total mass of the products equals the total mass of the reactants. This is the law of conservation of mass. For example, 8.0 g of copper joins with 2.0 g of oxygen to make 10.0 g of copper oxide. Because mass is conserved, we can work out a missing mass by adding or subtracting. Sometimes a balance seems to disagree. A pad of iron wool gains mass as it rusts, because oxygen and water from the damp air join it. A reaction in an open container loses mass if a gas, such as carbon dioxide, escapes. In a closed system the total stays the same. If one reactant runs out first, the reaction stops and the extra of the other reactant is left over, so it is not part of the product’s mass. If a result is unexpected, scientists do not ignore it: they check the equipment, look for gas that came in or got out, and repeat the measurement. One result that does not fit the others is anomalous, and the mean is worked out without it.
Situation
Mass reading
Reason
rusting iron wool in damp air
increases
oxygen and water from the air join the iron
fizzing in an open cup
decreases
carbon dioxide escapes into the air
same fizzing in a closed container
stays the same
the gas cannot escape
sugar dissolving in water
stays the same
no atoms are lost; no gas leaves
Worked examples
Copper (g)
Oxygen (g)
Copper oxide (g)
8.0
2.0
10.0
6.0
1.5
7.5
9.6
2.4
12.0
Missing masses with conservation of mass. When copper reacts with oxygen to form copper oxide, the total of the first two masses equals the third.
Results from a school test: baking soda was added to an excess of vinegar in an open flask on a balance. The line is drawn through the trend. The point at 4.0 g is lower than the line, so it is anomalous. A possible cause is that some of the baking soda stayed on the spoon, so less than 4.0 g went into the flask.
unexpected result→check the equipment and the method→repeat the measurement→if it still happens, look for a new explanation→if it was a slip, leave it out of the mean and say so
What to do with an unexpected result. A result that does not fit the pattern must be tested, not thrown away without a reason.
Class activity
Weigh a reaction. With an adult, on a tray. You need a kitchen scale, a tall cup, a small bowl, vinegar, baking soda and a spoon. Part A: put a cup with water and a spoon of sugar beside it on the scale and note the mass. Stir the sugar into the water and read the mass again. Part B: stand a cup holding about 60 g of vinegar inside a bowl on the scale (to catch any foam) and put one level teaspoon of baking soda in a small pot beside it. Read the total mass. Tip the baking soda slowly into the vinegar, keep your face back, wait until the fizzing has stopped and read again. Predict first, then repeat B three times and write down the mean. Which part loses mass, and where do you think it has gone? A scale showing whole grams gives only a rough answer. Why is this not a closed system? Wash your hands.
Practice
1
12 g of magnesium burns completely in 8 g of oxygen. What mass of magnesium oxide is formed, and how much of it is magnesium? Then 20 g of magnesium is heated by a teacher with the same 8 g of oxygen only: what mass of magnesium oxide forms, and why?
Magnesium (g)
Oxygen (g)
Magnesium oxide (g)
12
8
?
The magnesium oxide has a mass of 12 + 8 = 20 g. The magnesium in it is 12 g, because atoms of magnesium are not lost. With 20 g of magnesium and only 8 g of oxygen, the oxygen runs out first. Still 20 g of magnesium oxide forms, and 8 g of magnesium is left over.
2
A flask with limestone chips and acid reads 150.0 g. After the fizzing stops, the open flask reads 147.8 g. Where did 2.2 g go? How could the pupil show that mass is conserved?
Reading
Mass (g)
before
150.0
after
147.8
The carbon dioxide gas escaped into the air. To show conservation, use a closed container or collect and weigh the gas, so the total can be compared.
3
A pupil repeats a test and gets these masses lost: 2.1 g, 2.2 g, 3.9 g and 2.1 g. Which is anomalous? What mean should be reported, and what should the pupil do about the odd result?
Test
1
2
3
4
mass lost (g)
2.1
2.2
3.9
2.1
3.9 g is anomalous. The mean of 2.1, 2.2 and 2.1 is 2.1 g (to one decimal place). The pupil should check what could have gone wrong, repeat the test and say the 3.9 g result was left out.
4
A candle on a balance gets lighter as it burns. Does that break the law of conservation of mass? Explain.
No. The wax joins with oxygen to make carbon dioxide and water vapour, which go into the air. If all products and the oxygen used were weighed, the totals would match.