GoalUse a table of displacement results to put metals in order, identify metals and judge a plan.
New words
prediction · a statement of what you think will happen, made before the testevidence · observations and measurements that support or challenge an ideaidentify · find out what something isvalid · giving a fair answer to the question asked
Explanation
A grid of displacement results can be used to put metals in order. A metal that displaces many others is high in the series; one that displaces none is at the bottom. To rank four metals, count the reactions for each, then check the pattern is consistent. A result of ‘no reaction’ may only mean the reaction is too slow to see, so a good test gives it enough time. A fair test uses the same volume and strength of solution, the same size of metal piece, and the same temperature. Then you can identify an unknown metal by comparing its pattern with metals that you know. Conclusions are only about the metals tested.
Step
What you do
1
draw a grid of metals against solutions
2
record a tick for a reaction and a cross for none
3
count the ticks for each metal
4
order the metals, most ticks first
5
check that the order explains every result
Worked examples
Metal added →
W
X
Y
Z
W nitrate
✗
✓
✗
X nitrate
✓
✓
✓
Y nitrate
✗
✗
✗
Z nitrate
✓
✗
✓
Results for four metals W, X, Y and Z, each added to a solution of the others' nitrates. Y has three ticks, W two, Z one and X none. Order of reactivity: Y, W, Z, X.
Metal
Most likely
Reason
Y
magnesium (given)
displaces every other metal
W
zinc or iron
between magnesium and the less reactive metals
Z
copper
below W, above silver
X
silver (given)
displaces none
Identifying the metals. Y reacts with all the others, and X with none. If Y is magnesium and X is silver, W could be zinc and Z could be copper. Other choices, such as iron for W, would also fit; more tests with other metals would be needed to be sure.
Variable
Fair test?
Change
volume of solution
not the same
use the same volume
temperature
not the same
keep the same
size of metal piece
not stated
use the same size
Is the plan fair? A pupil plans to compare four metals by adding each to a different volume of solution at a different temperature.
Class activity
Predict, then compare. With an adult. Draw a grid with the metals magnesium, zinc, iron and copper along the top and the nitrates of each of them down the side (leave out any pair where the metal and the salt are the same). Use the reactivity series to fill in your predictions with ticks and crosses. Then ask a teacher to show you a displacement reaction, or watch a clear video from a school science source, and compare. Which predictions were right? Why might a reaction look as if it has not happened? What would you do to be surer about a ‘no’? Remember that you never try these reactions yourself.
Practice
1
Three metals G, H and J were tested. Put them in order of reactivity, most reactive first, and explain.
Metal added →
G
H
J
G salt
✓
✗
H salt
✗
✗
J salt
✓
✓
H, then G, then J. H displaces both of the others, G displaces only J, and J displaces none.
2
Why must the pieces of metal in such a test be the same size and the solutions the same strength?
If they differed, a faster reaction could be due to the bigger surface or stronger solution rather than the metal, so you could not tell which metal is more reactive.
3
A student says, ‘Metal J did not react with the solution in one minute, so J must be less reactive.’ What is the problem and what should the student do?
A slow reaction could be missed in one minute. The student should leave it longer, repeat the test and look for small changes such as a colour change or a coating.
4
A metal Q displaces silver from silver nitrate but does not displace iron from iron sulfate. Where can Q be in the series, and which metal from this week could it be?
Q is more reactive than silver but less reactive than iron. In this week’s series the only metal between them is copper, so Q could be copper.