GoalDescribe a potometer and a mass method for measuring transpiration, and judge how reliable the results are.
New words
potometer ยท apparatus that measures how fast a cut shoot takes up water by following an air bubble along a thin tubecontrol ยท a set-up kept the same except for the one thing being tested, so that you can comparereliable ยท giving similar results when the test is repeatedassumption ยท something taken to be true without testing it
Explanation
A potometer is apparatus for measuring how fast a cut shoot takes up water. The shoot is fitted tightly into a tube full of water that joins a thin side tube with one air bubble in it. As the shoot takes up water, the bubble moves along a scale. The rate is the distance the bubble moves divided by the time. A potometer measures uptake, not loss, so it assumes that nearly all the water taken up is lost by transpiration; a little is used in photosynthesis. A second method is to weigh a shoot standing in a jar and find the loss of mass over time. A control jar with no shoot shows how much water is lost in other ways. Repeat readings, ignore an anomalous result and give a mean.
Part of a potometer
Job
leafy shoot, cut under water
takes up water and transpires
tube full of water
carries water from the supply to the shoot
thin side tube with one air bubble
the bubble moves as water is taken up
scale beside the thin tube
shows how far the bubble moves
Worked examples
Reading
1
2
3
4
distance (mm)
42
45
71
44
Four readings of how far the bubble moved in 5 minutes under a lamp. 71 mm is anomalous. The mean of the other three is 131 รท 3 = 43.7 mm, so the rate is 43.7 รท 5 = 8.7 mm per minute.
A potted shoot in a jar was weighed each morning. The mean loss of mass per day is (540 โ 517) รท 2 = 11.5 g per day.
Assumption
Is it checked?
no water evaporates from the top of the jar
yes, with an oil layer
no water evaporates from the sides
a control jar with no shoot shows this
the shoot uses almost no water for photosynthesis
not checked; it is a small amount
Can we say that the mass lost equals the transpiration of the shoot? Check the assumptions.
Class activity
How much water does a shoot lose in a day? With an adult. Fill two identical jars with the same volume of water and a teaspoon of oil on top. Stand a leafy stem in jar A; leave jar B with no stem as the control. Weigh each jar on a kitchen scale and record the masses. Put both on the same shaded windowsill. Weigh them again after 24 hours. Find the loss of mass in each. If your scale only reads to 1 g, use a large leafy branch. Predict first. Why is jar B needed? What would you do to make the result more reliable? What does the scale's smallest step tell you about how exact your result is?
Practice
1
Four readings of the bubble movement in 5 minutes were 36, 39, 38 and 55 mm. Find the mean without the anomalous result and the rate in mm per minute.
Reading
1
2
3
4
distance (mm)
36
39
38
55
55 mm is anomalous. The mean of the others is (36 + 39 + 38) รท 3 = 37.7 mm, so the rate is 37.7 รท 5 = 7.5 mm per minute.
2
Give two reasons why the water taken up by a shoot may not equal the water it loses by transpiration.
A little water is used in photosynthesis and to keep cells firm, so it is not lost. Also, if the apparatus leaks or water evaporates elsewhere, the readings are not just the shoot's loss.
3
Two pot plants were weighed over three days. Work out how much mass each plant lost per day on average. Which plant lost water faster, and why must you be careful about the reason?
Plant G lost (610 โ 574) รท 3 = 12 g per day. Plant H lost (410 โ 392) รท 3 = 6 g per day. G lost faster. But we do not know why: G may have more leaves, or a different place or soil.
4
Plan a fair test to find out if the amount of light changes how fast a shoot loses water. Say what you change, what you measure and three things you keep the same.
Change: the amount of light (a lamp on or off at the same distance, or brighter and dimmer lamps). Measure: the loss of mass or the bubble movement per hour. Keep the same: the type and size of shoot, the temperature, the air movement, the humidity, the time.