GoalDraw and read a graph of water uptake, deal with an anomalous result and write a conclusion that matches the evidence.
New words
anomalous result · a result that does not fit the pattern of the othersline of best fit · a smooth line or curve drawn to follow the pattern of the pointsmean · the total of the readings divided by the number of readingsconclusion · a statement of what the results show, no more and no less
Explanation
Results about water uptake are easiest to see on a graph. Put the thing you changed, such as time, on the horizontal axis and the thing you measured on the vertical axis. Plot every point, then circle any point that does not fit the pattern: that is an anomalous result. Repeat it if you can; if not, leave it out of the line and say so. Draw the line of best fit. Describe the pattern with numbers from the graph, and then write a conclusion that matches the evidence. A conclusion should not say more than the experiment tested: an experiment on three plants in one week cannot show what all plants do all year. When plants differ in size, compare the water taken up per gram of plant.
results table→graph: what you changed on the horizontal axis→circle any anomalous result→draw the line of best fit→write a conclusion that matches the data
Worked examples
A pot plant with a tube in its soil took up water during one day. The uptake each hour was measured every two hours. The point at 14:00 does not fit the smooth curve, so it is anomalous; the curve is drawn without it.
Conclusion
Matches the data?
Why
uptake was greatest in the middle of the afternoon
yes
the curve is highest around 14:00 to 16:00
plants always take up the most water at 15:00
no
only one plant on one day was tested
sunshine causes the water uptake to rise
not shown
light was not measured or changed, so the data cannot show it
Which conclusion matches the graph above?
Variety
Mass of plants
Water taken up
Water per gram
P
8 g
36 cm³
36 ÷ 8 = 4.5 cm³ per g
Q
12 g
48 cm³
48 ÷ 12 = 4.0 cm³ per g
Two kinds of basil were grown. Variety P is smaller than variety Q. Per gram, P took up more water, even though Q took up more in total.
Class activity
Water through the day. With an adult. Put a cut stem of a leafy plant (mint, basil or ivy) in a jar of tap water. Pour on a teaspoon of cooking oil so that water cannot evaporate from the top. Mark the water level with a pen and measure the mark from the jar's rim with a ruler. Do this every two hours from morning to evening. Make a table, and plot a line graph of the fall in the level against the time. Circle any anomalous point. The level changes by only a few millimetres, so say how sure you are of each reading, and how a second jar would help. Write one sentence that matches your graph and does not say more than it shows.
Practice
1
Readings of the water taken up in one hour by the same seedlings on five mornings were 3.2, 3.4, 3.1, 5.9 and 3.3 cm³. Which is anomalous, and what is the mean without it?
5.9 cm³ is anomalous. The mean of the others is (3.2 + 3.4 + 3.1 + 3.3) ÷ 4 = 13.0 ÷ 4 = 3.25, about 3.3 cm³.
2
From the graph, estimate the uptake at 11:00. Is this a reading or an estimate, and why does that matter?
About 3.1 cm³ per hour. It is an estimate, found by joining the points at 10:00 and 12:00 and reading halfway between them, so it is less certain than a measured reading at 10:00 or 12:00.
3
A student writes: ‘Water uptake is greatest in the afternoon, so plants should only be watered in the afternoon.’ Say why this does not follow from the data.
The data show when one plant took up the most water; they do not show when watering is best. Other things, such as how much water the soil holds and the weather, were not tested.
4
Two kinds of tomato plant took up water. Kind R: 25 g took up 80 cm³. Kind S: 40 g took up 120 cm³. Which took up more water per gram?
Kind R: 80 ÷ 25 = 3.2 cm³ per g. Kind S: 120 ÷ 40 = 3.0 cm³ per g. R took up slightly more per gram, though S took up more in total.