Moving from hot to cold; ways of transferring thermal energy
Week 10 · Unit 3 · 3.4–3.5 · 3 lessons
3
Keep it hot, keep it cold
Workbook 9: Topics 3.4–3.5, pp. 57–62
GoalChoose materials and designs by thinking about conduction, convection and radiation, and plan a test of insulators.
New words
insulator · a material that is a poor conductor of thermal energytrapped air · small pockets of air that are a poor conductor and cannot circulate, so they reduce convectionabsorb · to take in radiationreflect · to bounce radiation back from a surface
Explanation
Engineers choose materials by how well they let thermal energy through. Metals are good conductors, so pans and radiator panels are made of metal. Insulators such as wool, foam and feathers are poor conductors, and they also hold trapped air in tiny pockets. Air is a poor conductor and in small pockets it cannot circulate, so convection is reduced too. Surfaces matter for radiation: dark, matt surfaces absorb and give out radiation well, while shiny, light-coloured surfaces reflect it and are poor at giving it out. A vacuum flask reduces all three transfers. The vacuum between its double walls stops conduction and convection, and the shiny walls reflect radiation. To keep something hot or cold, reduce the rate of transfer; you slow it down, you never stop it completely.
Feature
Which transfer it reduces
Example
trapped air
conduction and convection
a duvet, a woolly hat
shiny surface
radiation
foil blanket
lid or stopper
convection (and evaporation)
a flask stopper
vacuum gap
conduction and convection
a vacuum flask
Worked examples
Item
Material
Reason
oven glove
thick cotton
poor conductor, traps air
radiator panel
aluminium or steel
good conductor
cool box
foam with a pale outside
poor conductor, reflects radiation
kettle handle
plastic
insulator, stays cool to touch
Choosing materials for a job.
Four identical mugs start with warm water at 60 °C. After 20 minutes the temperature depends on what is round the mug.
Claim
Correct?
Fix
a woolly jumper gives you energy to keep you warm
no
it reduces the rate at which thermal energy leaves your body
a metal bar feels colder than a wooden bar at the same room temperature, so it is colder
no
both are at the same temperature; metal conducts energy away from your hand faster
a shiny surface stops all thermal energy getting in
no
it reflects radiation, but conduction and convection can still transfer energy
Spot the mistake. Each claim is about thermal energy transfer.
Class activity
Which wrapping keeps water warm longest? With an adult. The adult pours the same amount of warm tap water, about 200 mL and comfortably warm, into three identical mugs. Wrap one in a woolly sock, one in kitchen foil, and leave one bare. Put a saucer on top of each as a lid. Read the temperature of each mug at the start, after 10 minutes and after 20 minutes. Predict the order of the three before you start. Which variables must be the same? Look at your results: which wrapping is the best insulator? Which result, if any, looks odd, and how could you check it?
Practice
1
A window has two sheets of glass with a thin layer of air sealed between them. Explain how this reduces the thermal energy lost from a warm room.
Air is a poor conductor, so little energy is conducted across the gap. The gap is thin, so the air cannot circulate much, which reduces convection. This slows down the transfer of thermal energy through the window.
2
Two cans of drink stand in the same sunshine, one painted shiny silver and one painted matt black. After 20 minutes their temperatures are shown. Explain the difference and suggest the best colour for a cover to keep drinks cool on a picnic. Name one thing that must be kept the same.
Can
Start (°C)
After 20 min (°C)
shiny silver
8
15
matt black
8
22
The matt black can absorbed more radiation from the Sun, so it warmed more. A shiny silver or pale cover reflects radiation and is best for keeping drinks cool. The cans must be at the same distance from the light and start at the same temperature.
3
A small bird fluffs up its feathers on a cold morning. Explain how this helps it to lose less thermal energy.
The fluffed-up feathers hold a thicker layer of trapped air, which is a poor conductor and cannot circulate easily. This reduces conduction and convection, so thermal energy leaves the bird’s body more slowly.
4
Design a lunch box for keeping a cold drink cold. Give three features, and say which kind of transfer each one reduces.
Examples: a foam lining (reduces conduction, trapped air also reduces convection), a shiny or pale outside surface (reflects radiation), a tight lid (reduces convection and the warm air getting in). Any three that match the correct kind of transfer.