GoalPlan a fair test, record repeated results, deal with an anomalous result and write a conclusion that fits the evidence.
New words
hypothesis ยท an idea that can be tested and that predicts what will happencontrol variable ยท a variable that you keep the same so that the test is fairanomalous result ยท a result that does not fit the pattern of the othersmean ยท the total of the values divided by how many values there are
Explanation
A water plant such as pondweed gives off bubbles of oxygen when it photosynthesises, so counting bubbles each minute lets you compare rates. Start with a hypothesis, for example โthe closer the light, the more bubblesโ. The distance of the light is the independent variable and the number of bubbles in one minute is the dependent variable. The control variables are the same piece of pondweed, the same water temperature, the same volume of water and the same counting time. Use a cool LED light, because a hot bulb would warm the water and change a second variable. Repeat each distance three times and work out a mean, leaving out any anomalous result, such as a count where bubbles were missed. Then plot a graph. A good conclusion matches the evidence and mentions limits: counting bubbles by eye is not exact, and bubbles differ in size.
Type of variable
In this test
independent (changed)
distance of the light from the beaker
dependent (measured)
number of bubbles in one minute
control (kept the same)
same pondweed, same water, same temperature, same counting time
Worked examples
Distance (cm)
Try 1
Try 2
Try 3
Mean
10
31
29
30
30
20
19
20
9
19.5
40
8
9
7
8
A results table. At 20 cm the third count (9) does not fit the other two, so it is anomalous and is left out. Mean at 20 cm = (19 + 20) รท 2 = 19.5.
The means plotted. The line falls as the light moves away. With only three distances the exact shape is uncertain, so more distances would give a better picture.
Weakness
Better method
counting by eye is tiring and bubbles are missed
a partner counts, or the test is filmed and counted afterwards
a hot lamp warms the water
use a cool LED light
the plant was moved straight from a different light
leave it for two minutes at each new distance
Improving a plan. Each weakness changes how reliable the results are.
Class activity
Bubble count at home, with an adult. You need a clear jar of tap water that has stood in the room for an hour, a sprig of a water plant from a pet shop or a pond (the adult supplies it), and a battery LED torch that the adult props on books at 10 cm, then 20 cm, then 40 cm from the jar. Do not use anything plugged into a socket. Wait two minutes at each distance, then count the bubbles from the cut end of the stem for one minute. Do each distance three times, record the counts in a table, work out the means and draw a bar chart. Wash your hands afterwards. If you have no water plant, write the plan and the results table on paper instead.
Practice
1
Nodira changes the mass of pondweed (1 g, 2 g and 3 g) in three identical jars and counts the bubbles each gives off in a minute. Name the independent variable, the dependent variable and two control variables.
Independent: the mass of pondweed. Dependent: the number of bubbles in one minute. Controls, any two of: the same kind of pondweed, the same lamp and distance, the same water temperature, the same volume of water, the same counting time.
2
Four counts of bubbles in one minute are in the table. Which is anomalous, and what is the mean without it?
Try 1
Try 2
Try 3
Try 4
12
13
25
11
The count of 25 is anomalous. The mean is (12 + 13 + 11) รท 3 = 12 bubbles per minute.
3
The adult adds pinches of baking soda to the jar water; each pinch releases more dissolved carbon dioxide for the plant. The chart shows bubbles per minute for each amount. Write a conclusion, and suggest why 2 and 4 pinches gave the same result.
More carbon dioxide gave more bubbles up to 2 pinches, so carbon dioxide was limiting at first. At 2 and 4 pinches the rate was the same, so another factor, such as light or temperature, had become limiting.
4
Give two reasons why counts can differ between repeats even when the test is kept fair, and one way to improve the method.
Bubbles differ in size, bubbles are missed when counting by eye, and the plant may change over time. Improvements: more repeats, filming, or collecting the gas in a measuring tube to measure its volume.