For, against and feelings
In a debate, one team speaks for the motion and one speaks against it. Good speakers give a clear point, a reason and an example. Notes use short forms, but a speech uses full sentences: ‘roads – busy – summer’ becomes ‘The roads are very busy in summer.’ Connect ideas with firstly, in addition, however, as a result and on the other hand. Participle adjectives end in -ing or -ed. An -ing adjective describes the thing or person that causes the feeling: a tiring walk, a surprising result, a confusing map. An -ed adjective describes how a person feels or what has been affected: a tired guide, surprised pupils, confused visitors. Some -ed adjectives describe a state: crowded streets, a damaged wall, a protected beach. We can make them stronger or weaker with intensifiers: really alarming, rather disappointed. With strong adjectives we use absolutely or completely (absolutely exhausted), not very. Use a rebuttal to answer the last point: ‘My opponent said … but …’
| -ing (the cause) | -ed (the feeling or state) |
|---|---|
| a fascinating museum | I was fascinated by the museum. |
| a tiring journey | We felt extremely tired. |
| a surprising result | The pupils were very surprised. |
| a confusing map | The visitors were confused. |
| FOR | AGAINST |
|---|---|
| less crowding for residents | shops and cafés lose customers |
| old stones less damaged | only rich people can book places |
| calmer visit for tourists | hard to control the numbers |
| time for repairs | people go to other places and crowd them |
| note | sentence |
|---|---|
| old stones less damaged | Old buildings would be damaged less if fewer people walked on them. |
| shops lose customers | Many shops could lose customers and some might close. |
| hard to control numbers | It would be difficult to control the numbers fairly. |
We support the motion. Firstly, crowded streets spoil life for residents: a woman who has lived next to the old market for fifty years told me that in summer she cannot even reach her own front door. In addition, the ancient stones are being damaged by millions of feet. As a result, visitors themselves are disappointed when the monuments are hidden behind crowds.
Mini-debate. Choose the motion ‘Our town should hold a big music festival every summer’ or one of your own. Divide into ‘for’ and ‘against’. Each side speaks for one minute with three points, each with a reason and an example. Then each side gives a 20-second rebuttal beginning ‘My opponent said … but …’. The listeners vote and say which argument had the best example.
…