GoalStudy a ‘for and against’ essay: its parts, its formal style and the connectives that link the arguments.
New words
supporter · a person who agrees with an idea and wants it to succeedcritic · a person who says what is wrong with somethingevidence · facts or examples that show that a statement is truebalanced · giving a fair chance to both sidesformal · serious and polite in style, without slang or short formsconclusion · the last part of a text, which sums up the ideas
Explanation
A ‘for and against’ essay looks at both sides of a question before the writer gives a view. It has an introduction, which presents the topic and the question but does not give your opinion yet. The middle paragraphs give the arguments. You can put all the ‘for’ arguments together and then all the ‘against’ arguments (block order), or you can take one point at a time and give both views on it (point-by-point order, as in the model). Support every argument with evidence or an example. The conclusion sums up and gives your reasoned opinion. The style is formal: no slang, no short forms such as don’t, and few personal phrases in the body. Use linking words such as Supporters argue …, Critics reply …, Nevertheless, whereas, Although, A second point concerns … and To sum up. These make the essay balanced and easy to follow.
part
job
language in the model
introduction
present the question; do not give your opinion yet
To sum up; Taking everything into account, I believe that …
Worked examples
Are video-game tournaments sports?
Video-game tournaments now fill large halls and attract millions of viewers online. This raises a question: should they be called sports, or are they simply entertainment? This essay looks at the main arguments on both sides, point by point, before reaching a conclusion.
The first point concerns skill. Supporters argue that top players need abilities similar to those of athletes: they react in a fraction of a second, plan several moves ahead and stay calm under pressure. Critics reply that a sport should test the body, and that sitting at a screen cannot be compared with running or swimming. Nevertheless, shooting and chess are treated as sports in many countries, although they hardly use the legs.
A second point concerns training. Professional teams practise for many hours a day, follow a timetable and work with coaches, just as football clubs do. Opponents of the idea say that players spend too much time indoors, whereas athletes keep fit. This is a serious concern, but it is a reason for players to exercise as well, not an argument against the competition itself.
Finally, there is the question of young people. Supporters believe that tournaments teach teamwork and fair play. However, critics worry that long hours in front of a screen can harm sleep and eyesight, and that big prizes may encourage children to play for too long.
To sum up, both sides have strong arguments. Taking everything into account, I believe that tournaments can be called sports if they have fair rules and trained referees, provided that players also look after their health.
A model ‘for and against’ essay (written for this lesson). Listen, then read it again part by part.
block order
point-by-point order
paragraph 2: all the arguments for
paragraph 2: point 1, for and against
paragraph 3: all the arguments against
paragraph 3: point 2, for and against
conclusion
paragraph 4: point 3, for and against, then the conclusion
Two ways to organise the arguments.
informal
formal
Loads of kids reckon it’s unfair.
Many young people believe that it is unfair.
It costs a fortune.
It is very expensive.
Anyway, I think it’s fine.
In conclusion, I believe that it is acceptable.
From informal to formal.
Class activity
Spot the side. Cut the model essay into sentences, or copy them on cards. In pairs, sort the cards into two piles: arguments for and arguments against. Then find the sentences that link the two sides and underline the connective in each. Finally, close the book and give a one-minute spoken summary of the essay, point by point, using Supporters argue … and Critics reply …
Practice
1
Answer about the model essay. a) What question does it ask? b) Is the order block or point-by-point? c) Name two points on which supporters and critics disagree. d) What is the writer’s opinion, and which words introduce it?
a) Should video-game tournaments be called sports? b) Point-by-point. c) For example skill (react quickly vs the body is not tested), training (like football clubs vs too much time indoors), young people (teamwork vs screen time). d) Tournaments can be called sports if they have fair rules and trained referees, provided that players look after their health; introduced by Taking everything into account, I believe that …
2
Rewrite each sentence in a formal style. a) Loads of people reckon games are rubbish for your eyes. b) Pro players get tons of money, which is great. c) Anyway, I reckon it’s OK if the rules are fair.
a) Many people believe that video games are harmful to the eyes. b) Professional players earn large amounts of money, which is an advantage. c) In conclusion, I believe that it is acceptable provided that the rules are fair.
3
Choose from the box: Nevertheless, whereas, To sum up, Moreover, Critics reply. a) Football needs a large field, ___ chess needs only a table. b) The costs are high. ___, many schools have bought the equipment. c) ___, the arguments in favour are stronger than those against. d) Exercise improves health. ___, it helps students to concentrate. e) Supporters say that the prizes are fair. ___ that they are too large.
a) whereas; b) Nevertheless; c) To sum up; d) Moreover; e) Critics reply.
4
Argument: ‘Playing chess helps young people to concentrate.’ Which sentence is the best evidence? a) Chess is the best game in the world. b) Teachers in several schools reported that pupils who played chess once a week stayed focused for longer in lessons. c) My uncle plays chess and he is clever.
b) It gives a general observation by several teachers. a) is only an opinion; c) is one example and does not show a link.
5
Writing. Write the introduction (three or four sentences) of an essay on the question ‘Should every pupil take part in a school sports day?’ Present the topic, say what the question is and say how the essay is organised. Do not give your opinion yet.
part
your notes
topic
?
the question
?
how the essay is organised
?
For example: School sports days have been part of school life for many years. Recently, however, some teachers and parents have asked whether every pupil should be obliged to take part. This essay considers the main arguments for and against, one point at a time, before reaching a conclusion.