Guessing what must have happened
To guess about the past we use must have, can’t have or might have, followed by a past participle. Use must have when you are almost sure that something happened, because of clues: The window is open, so someone must have come in. Use might have when it is possible but you are not sure: She might have missed the bus. Use can’t have when you are almost sure that something did not happen, because the facts do not fit: He can’t have forgotten; he wrote the date on his hand. For a possible negative, use might not have: They might not have heard the bell. First look at the clue, then make the guess. The more exact your feeling word is, the better your guess: a person who is relieved and a person who is jealous behave differently.
| phrase | meaning | example |
|---|---|---|
| must have + past participle | almost sure it happened | The lights are off, so they must have left. |
| might have + past participle | possible, not sure | He might have lost his phone. |
| can’t have + past participle | almost sure it did not happen | She can’t have heard us; she was wearing headphones. |
Look at Kwame. He is sitting alone, and he seems very restless.
He must have lost something important. He was cheerful this morning.
Or he might have argued with his brother. They sometimes fall out.
He can’t have lost the match, because the game is tomorrow.
True. Let’s ask him. He might feel relieved to talk.
| clue | guess | feeling |
|---|---|---|
| A boy holds a cup and jumps in the air. | He must have won. | overjoyed |
| Two girls laugh in the rain without umbrellas. | They might have forgotten them, but they can’t have minded. | content |
| A man looks at a pile of letters and bills. | He might have been away for weeks. | overwhelmed |
| feeling | possible reason |
|---|---|
| relieved | the exam is over |
| jealous | a friend won the prize |
| ashamed | he told a lie |
| overwhelmed | too many tasks and too little time |
| content | nothing is missing today |
| restless | she is waiting for news |
Mystery guesses. One person describes a clue, for example ‘The kitchen floor is wet and there is a bucket in the middle.’ The others say what must have, might have or can’t have happened, and which feeling the person in the story had. Take turns. Give a point for each sensible guess that uses the right form.