GoalTalk about jobs and what they need, and use who, which and that in defining and extra-information relative clauses.
New words
architect · a person who designs buildingsparamedic · a health worker who gives emergency help before a patient reaches hospitalinterpreter · a person who says aloud in another language what someone is sayingaccountant · a person who keeps and checks records of moneyqualification · an exam result or certificate that shows you can do a jobemployer · a person or company that pays people to work for them
Explanation
A relative clause gives more information about a noun. Use who for people, which for things, and that for either one in a defining clause. A defining clause tells us which person or thing we mean, so it has no commas: An interpreter is a person who translates speech aloud. An extra-information clause only adds a detail. It has commas, and you cannot use that in it: My aunt, who is a pilot, lives in Bukhara. Which can also comment on a whole idea that came before it: She repaired the lift herself, which saved the school a lot of money. Do not say the person which or a thing who.
kind of clause
pattern
example
defining, person
noun + who / that + verb
A paramedic is someone who helps in an emergency.
defining, thing
noun + which / that + verb
The course that I want takes two years.
extra information
noun, who / which …,
Our neighbour, who is an architect, drew the plan.
whole idea
clause, which + verb
The shop opened late, which annoyed the customers.
Worked examples
Farida
How was the careers fair? Which stall did you like best?
Tomas
The one that was run by paramedics. A woman who works on an ambulance showed us her bag, which was packed with equipment.
Farida
Would you want a job that is so stressful?
Tomas
Perhaps. My cousin, who is an accountant, can work from home on Fridays, which I would enjoy. But I would like to be useful.
Farida
I talked to an interpreter who works at conferences. She says the hardest part is listening and speaking at the same time.
Tomas
Which languages does she use?
Farida
Three. She learned the third one in a city where nobody spoke her own language, which must have been difficult.
Two friends talk about a careers fair. Listen for who and which.
from the talk
kind of clause
A woman who works on an ambulance
defining (person)
a job that is so stressful
defining (thing)
My cousin, who is an accountant,
extra information
…her bag, which was packed with equipment
extra information about a thing
…nobody spoke her language, which must have been difficult
comment on the whole idea
Sort the clauses from the talk.
Say the job words aloud.
Class activity
Mystery job. One player thinks of a job (not one from the lesson) and says, ‘I am a person who …’ or ‘I am someone who …’ with one clue at a time. The others guess after each clue. After the guess, the player adds one extra-information sentence with commas, such as ‘An electrician, who needs a licence, can work in homes.’ Take turns and count the clues each job needed.
Practice
1
Write who, which or that. If two answers are possible, write both. a) The mechanic ___ repaired our car was very polite. b) My aunt, ___ is a nurse, works at night. c) The course ___ I want starts in September. d) Aziz fixed the lift in ten minutes, ___ impressed the manager.
a) who / that; b) who (that is not possible between commas); c) which / that; d) which (it comments on the whole idea).
2
Join the two sentences with the word in brackets. a) I know a woman. She translates books. (who) b) My brother has a laptop. It is very old. (which) c) My grandmother lives in Termez. She is a retired teacher. (Put the second sentence in the middle, between commas, with who.)
a) I know a woman who translates books. b) My brother has a laptop which is very old. c) My grandmother, who is a retired teacher, lives in Termez.
3
Correct the mistake in each sentence. a) The interpreter which spoke at the meeting was excellent. b) My neighbour, that is an accountant, helped me. c) It rained all week, what spoiled the trip. d) The job who I want needs a degree.
a) The interpreter who (or that) spoke at the meeting was excellent. b) My neighbour, who is an accountant, helped me. c) It rained all week, which spoiled the trip. d) The job which (or that) I want needs a degree.
4
Write one sentence for each job that begins ‘A … is someone who …’. Choose three of: scientist, farmer, mechanic.
For example: A scientist is someone who does experiments to find out how things work. A farmer is someone who grows crops or keeps animals. A mechanic is someone who repairs engines and machines.
5
Writing. Write four sentences about the jobs of people you know. Use one defining clause with who, one defining clause with which or that, one extra-information clause between commas and one clause with ‘, which’ about a whole idea.
For example: I have a cousin who designs bridges. She works for a company that builds roads. My grandfather, who was a farmer, taught me to plant trees. He never used machines, which surprised me.