GoalTalk about rules with have to, mustn’t, don’t have to and passive verbs followed by to + infinitive.
New words
compulsory · something you must do because of a ruleoptional · something you can choose to do or not to doforbidden · not allowed at allenforce · to make people obey a rulefair · treating everyone in the same, reasonable wayconsequence · something that happens because of what you did
Explanation
Rules can be strong or weak, and English has different patterns for each. Use have to (or must) for something that is necessary: You have to wear goggles in the lab. Use mustn’t for something that is forbidden: You mustn’t run on the stairs. Be careful: don’t have to means that something is not necessary, so you can choose. Another way to talk about rules is the passive of allow, expect, encourage, suppose or forbid, followed by to + infinitive: We are allowed to sit outside. Students are expected to arrive on time. We are encouraged to join a club, but nobody forces us. A rule that says what the plan is, but not what always happens, uses supposed to: I am supposed to hand in my phone.
meaning
pattern
example
necessary
have to / must
You have to wear a blazer.
forbidden
mustn’t / are not allowed to
You mustn’t run on the stairs.
not necessary
don’t have to
You don’t have to wear a tie on Fridays.
permitted
are allowed to
We are allowed to bring a packed lunch.
hoped for or normal
are expected / encouraged to
We are expected to try one activity.
what the rule says
are supposed to
We are supposed to hand in phones.
Worked examples
Dilnoza
Is your school very strict, Marat?
Marat
Some things are. We have to wear a blazer, and we mustn’t run on the stairs.
Dilnoza
Do you have to wear a tie every day?
Marat
No, we don’t have to. On Fridays we are allowed to wear our sports kit.
Dilnoza
And phones?
Marat
We are supposed to hand them in at the start of the day, but some students forget.
Dilnoza
At my school we are encouraged to join a club, but it is optional.
Marat
Ours too, although we are expected to try at least one activity.
Two cousins compare their schools. Listen for the rule patterns.
strongest
weakest
forbidden
compulsory
expected
optional
You mustn’t
You have to
You are expected to
You don’t have to
Strong, weak, free: rules on a scale.
Say the rule words aloud.
Class activity
Rules for a school on the Moon. Work with a partner. Invent six rules for a school in a space station: two things that are compulsory, two that are forbidden and two that are optional. Write them with six different patterns from the table. Read your rules aloud, but leave out the key pattern word (say ‘beep’). Your partner has to guess the missing words.
Practice
1
Choose the right option. a) In the chemistry lab you (mustn’t / don’t have to) taste the chemicals. b) The museum is free, but you (mustn’t / don’t have to) take a leaflet. c) You (have to / don’t have to) show your ticket at the gate.
a) mustn’t; b) don’t have to; c) have to.
2
Complete the sentences with the passive form of the verb in brackets. a) (allow) Students ___ to use the library at break. b) (not / allow) Visitors ___ to park in the staff car park. c) (encourage) Pupils ___ to join a club, but it is their choice. d) (suppose) I ___ to hand in my essay today, but I have not finished it.
a) are allowed; b) are not allowed (aren’t allowed); c) are encouraged; d) am supposed.
3
Rewrite each sentence with the word in brackets. a) The school does not let students wear earrings. (allowed) b) Teachers want students to say sorry if they push someone. (expected) c) The plan says that we should meet at eight. (supposed)
a) Students are not allowed to wear earrings. b) Students are expected to say sorry if they push someone. c) We are supposed to meet at eight.
4
Sam says: ‘It’s Saturday, so I mustn’t get up early.’ Is Sam correct? Explain the mistake and give a better sentence.
No. Mustn’t means ‘it is forbidden’. Sam means that getting up early is not necessary, so: ‘I don’t have to get up early.’
5
Writing. Think of a place you know (a swimming pool, a library, a youth club). Write five sentences about its rules. Use have to, mustn’t, don’t have to and two passive patterns.
For example: At our pool you have to shower before you swim. You mustn’t run on the wet floor. Children under ten don’t have to wear a swimming cap. Swimmers are expected to keep to the right. We are not allowed to dive in the shallow end.