GoalUse the third conditional and if only + past perfect to talk about imagined pasts and regrets, and discuss a moral dilemma.
New words
dilemma · a hard choice between two things when each has a costconfess · to tell people that you did something wrongloyal · staying faithful to a friend or a groupconscience · the inner voice that tells you what is right and wrongtempted · wanting to do something that you know is not wiseregret · a sad feeling about something you did or did not do
Explanation
The third conditional is for the past as we imagine it, not as it was. The real past is different. The pattern is: if + past perfect, would / could / might have + past participle. If I had known the way, I would have arrived on time. (In fact, I did not know the way, so I was late.) Would shows that you are sure, could shows that it was possible, and might shows that it was only perhaps. You can put the result first: I would have arrived on time if I had known the way. We use if only + past perfect for a regret, and the result part is often left out: If only I had listened! Notice that ’d can mean had (If I’d known) or would (I’d have gone).
if-part (past perfect)
result part
what really happened
If she had studied,
she would have passed.
She did not study. She failed.
If we had left earlier,
we could have caught the train.
We left late. We missed it.
If only I had listened!
(I would have understood.)
I did not listen.
Worked examples
Last Saturday I borrowed my neighbour’s ladder to clear the gutter. While I was climbing down, one step cracked. Nobody saw it. When I returned the ladder, Mr Aziz was not at home, so I leaned it against his wall and said nothing. That night I could not sleep. If I had knocked on his door, I would have felt better. If only I had knocked, he could have mended the step before somebody climbed it. What do you think I should have done?
A short dilemma. Listen and then talk about it.
what happened
what I imagine
I did not knock on his door.
If I had knocked on his door, I would have felt better.
I did not warn him about the step.
If only I had warned him, he could have mended it.
I went home and said nothing.
If I had spoken to him, I might have slept well that night.
Real past and imagined past.
Say the dilemma words aloud.
Class activity
Dilemma cards. Write three short dilemmas on cards, for example: you saw a friend copy answers in a test; you borrowed a game and a piece got lost; a teammate asked you to say that the team had trained when it had not. Take turns to draw a card. The speaker says one sentence with If I had been … and one sentence with If only …. The group decides whether the sentences are correct and gives one reason for or against the choice.
Practice
1
Complete the sentences with the correct forms. Use would in the result. a) If Dina (study) harder, she (pass) the test. b) We (not / get) wet if we (take) an umbrella. c) If the bus (not / be) late, I (arrive) on time.
a) had studied, would have passed; b) would not (wouldn’t) have got, had taken; c) had not (hadn’t) been, would have arrived.
2
Combine each pair into one third-conditional sentence. a) He did not check the map. He got lost. (use would) b) They did not save any money. They could not buy the tickets. (use could)
a) If he had checked the map, he would not (wouldn’t) have got lost. b) If they had saved some money, they could have bought the tickets.
3
Write a regret with If only. a) You shouted at your friend and now she is upset. b) You left your homework on the bus.
a) If only I hadn’t shouted at her. b) If only I hadn’t left my homework on the bus. (If only I had taken my homework with me. is also correct.)
4
True or false? ‘If the shop had been open, I would have bought the book’ means that the shop was open and I bought the book.
False. It means that the shop was closed, so I did not buy the book.
5
Writing. Write a dilemma of about 60 words in which a person must choose between two things. End with the question ‘What do you think I should have done?’ Then write one sentence with a third conditional about what you would have done.
For example: My cousin lent me her camera for a trip. On the last day it fell on the stones and the lens cracked. She was not at home when I came back. I could have left the camera on her doorstep, or I could have waited and told her the truth. What do you think I should have done? — If I had waited for her, I would have told her the truth in person.