Anatomy of a for-and-against essay
A for-and-against essay has four parts. The introduction opens with a hook, such as a question, names the topic and hints at both sides. One paragraph gives the reasons for, and another gives the reasons against; each reason needs evidence or an example. The conclusion sums up the main points and gives your own opinion. Connectives link the ideas: adding (furthermore, in addition, moreover), result (consequently, as a result), contrast (however, whereas, nevertheless, although), examples (such as, for instance) and conclusion (in conclusion, to sum up). The style is formal: no slang, no contractions and no talking to the reader. Do not start every sentence with a connective, and put a comma after one at the start of a sentence.
Should cities switch off street lights at night?
Cities that never go dark are a modern wonder, but is it wise to light every street until dawn? Many people believe that bright streets are essential, whereas scientists increasingly warn that constant light harms nature and wastes energy.
There are strong reasons for keeping the lights on. First, well-lit streets help people to feel safe when they walk home late, and drivers can see cyclists and pedestrians more clearly. Furthermore, shops and cafés that stay open late create jobs. In addition, emergency services find addresses more quickly in a well-lit street.
However, constant light has serious disadvantages. Migrating birds can lose their way when they are drawn towards bright city centres, and baby sea turtles sometimes crawl towards street lights instead of the sea. Moreover, lighting a city all night uses a great deal of electricity, which is expensive and often produces carbon dioxide. Studies of sleep also suggest that bright light outside a window makes it harder for residents to rest.
Nevertheless, the choice is not simply between light and darkness. Lights can be dimmed after midnight, pointed downwards and fitted with sensors that switch them on only when somebody approaches.
In conclusion, although safety must come first, I believe that cities should dim their street lights late at night. This protects wildlife and saves money, and it still allows people to travel safely.
| job | connectives |
|---|---|
| adding | furthermore, in addition, moreover |
| result | consequently, as a result |
| contrast | however, whereas, nevertheless |
| example | such as, for instance |
| ending | in conclusion, to sum up |
| informal | formal |
|---|---|
| Kids can’t sleep when it’s bright. | Children cannot sleep when it is bright. |
| a lot of electricity | a great deal of electricity |
| So the town pays more. | Consequently, the town pays more. |
Essay detectives. Read the model essay (or an opinion article from home). Mark every connective with a colour for its job: one colour for adding, one for contrast, one for result and one for the ending. Count them. Then cover the connectives with sticky notes and ask a partner to say which could go in each gap. Is more than one answer possible?