Spot the slant
Bias means that feelings push a writer towards one side, and the other side is hidden. Look for clues. A generalisation uses words such as all, always, nobody and everyone. Loaded words, such as ridiculous or disgusting, show feelings and not facts. Also ask who will gain or lose, and where the proof is. A fair reader does not jump to conclusions: first weigh the evidence. A present participle clause can replace a relative clause when the verb is active and about now or in general: Shoppers who are hurrying to the market becomes Shoppers hurrying to the market. Do not use it for one finished past event, such as the man who broke the window.
| bias clue | example | question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| generalisation | Nobody in this town owns a bicycle. | Is this true of everyone? |
| loaded word | a ridiculous idea | Is this a fact or a feeling? |
| personal interest | written by a shop owner | Will this person gain or lose? |
| no proof | not one customer complained | Where is the evidence? |
Dear Editor. The council wants to build a cycle lane along Orchard Road. This is a ridiculous idea, typical of people who have never driven a delivery van. Cycle lanes in every town stand empty all winter, and nobody here owns a bicycle anyway. Shoppers hurrying to the market will be in danger, and traders like me will lose customers because nobody will be able to park. Only a fool would support this plan. Bekzod Nurmatov, shop owner.
Dear Editor. Everyone with a brain can see that Orchard Road needs a cycle lane. Drivers racing past the school at forty kilometres an hour are a danger to children, and the shopkeepers complaining about parking simply care about money. In my town, a new lane made the streets quiet and safe, and not one customer complained. The councillors who oppose it are living in the past. Elin Lindqvist, cyclist.
| relative clause | participle clause |
|---|---|
| shoppers who are hurrying to the market | shoppers hurrying to the market |
| the shopkeepers who complain about parking | the shopkeepers complaining about parking |
| a van that blocks the road | a van blocking the road |
| biased | fairer |
|---|---|
| Only a fool would support this plan. | I do not support this plan, because I am worried about parking. |
| Nobody in this town owns a bicycle. | Fewer people cycle here than in some other towns. |
Two sides of a story. Choose a topic (school uniform, phones in class, a new park). In pairs, each player writes two biased sentences, one with a generalisation and one with a loaded word. Swap papers. Your partner underlines the clue, says what question to ask, and rewrites the sentence fairly. Then hold a two-minute discussion in which nobody is allowed to use a generalisation.
| phrases |
|---|
| a) Nobody ever reads the notices. |
| b) The new lane will be 1.5 metres wide. |
| c) a disgusting, filthy canteen |
| d) All teenagers love loud music. |
| e) The library closes at six o’clock. |