GoalPlan, write and improve a ‘for and against’ essay step by step, and give useful feedback to another writer.
New words
draft · a first version of a piece of writingrevise · to change a text in order to make it bettertopic sentence · the sentence that tells the reader what a paragraph is aboutproofread · to read a text carefully to find mistakes in spelling and grammarfeedback · comments that tell you what is good and what could be betterconstructive · useful and meant to help
Explanation
Good writers work in steps. First, write the question and decide who the readers are. Second, list the arguments for and against in two columns, and add an example to each one. Third, choose the order of the paragraphs (block or point-by-point) and decide on your conclusion. Fourth, write a first draft. Begin every paragraph with a topic sentence, such as Three points support … or Critics, however, raise strong objections to …, and link the sentences with connectives. Fifth, revise: is every argument supported? Is the style formal? Are there repeated words? Finally, proofread for spelling, punctuation and grammar. When you give feedback, be constructive: say what works, then suggest one change, for example It would be even stronger if you added an example to your second point.
Write the question→List arguments and examples→Choose the order→Write a first draft→Revise→Proofread and share
Worked examples
for
against
motivation: pupils see a goal
shame: names near the bottom
progress: rising from 20th to 10th place
marks measure only some abilities
preparation for entrance exams
pupils study for marks, not for learning
A plan for an essay on the question ‘Should pupils be ranked by their marks?’
Many schools publish a list that shows which pupil has the highest marks. Some people welcome the list; others would prefer to abolish it. This essay considers both views before giving a conclusion.
Three points support ranking. The first is motivation: a list can make pupils work harder, because they can see what they could achieve. The second is progress, because a pupil who rises from twentieth to tenth place knows that revision has worked. In addition, ranking prepares young people for entrance exams, in which only a limited number of places is offered.
Critics, however, raise strong objections. To begin with, many pupils feel ashamed when their names appear near the bottom, and this may make them stop trying. Furthermore, marks measure only some abilities. A pupil who is gifted at music or sport does not appear on the list at all. Finally, some pupils may study only for the marks and not for the pleasure of learning.
Taking everything into account, I believe that schools should give each pupil private feedback instead of a public list. Competition can be healthy, provided that it does not make anyone feel worthless.
The finished essay from that plan (block order). Listen, then find the topic sentences.
check
question
content
Does each argument have an example?
order
Does each paragraph start with a topic sentence?
style
Is it formal, with no short forms or slang?
links
Are there connectives between and inside sentences?
accuracy
Spelling, punctuation, verb forms?
A revision checklist.
Class activity
Feedback circle. Swap your draft with a partner. Read it twice. On a card write: one thing that works well, one connective you liked, and one change that would make it stronger, beginning ‘It would be even stronger if …’. Talk about the card for two minutes, then revise your draft.
Practice
1
Make a plan for the question ‘Should every pupil have to take part in a school sports day?’ Give two arguments for and two against, each with an example.
for
against
?
?
?
?
For example: For: 1) health, since many teenagers sit for hours every day; 2) teamwork, since relay races and team games teach co-operation. Against: 1) pupils with injuries or who dislike competition feel embarrassed in public; 2) the day takes time from lessons and revision.
2
Which is the best topic sentence for a paragraph that gives three reasons against ranking pupils? a) Ranking is bad. b) Critics raise three strong objections to ranking pupils by their marks. c) My friend hates the list.
b) It tells the reader what the paragraph is about and is formal. a) is too short and has no focus; c) is personal and informal.
3
Improve this weak draft. Use formal language and at least three connectives. ‘Sport is good. It makes you fit. Also it’s fun. But some kids hate it. Loads of them get hurt.’
For example: Sport has several advantages. Firstly, it keeps pupils fit; in addition, many of them find it enjoyable. However, some pupils dislike it, and a number of them are injured every year. Nevertheless, with good supervision the benefits are greater than the risks.
4
Give two pieces of constructive feedback on this sentence from a draft: ‘In my opinion sports day is brilliant because it is brilliant.’
For example: 1) The reason repeats the opinion, so give a real reason (for example, it gets everybody moving). 2) Brilliant and In my opinion are informal for the body of an essay; try Sports day has several advantages.
5
Writing. Using your plan, write an essay of 150–200 words on the question ‘Should every pupil have to take part in a school sports day?’ Use point-by-point order, formal style, at least five connectives and a conclusion with your opinion.
An essay with an introduction, two points with both views, and a conclusion. For example: Many schools hold a sports day every year. This essay considers whether all pupils should be obliged to take part. The first point concerns health. Supporters argue that the day gets everybody moving, whereas critics reply that pupils who dislike sport only feel worse. The second point concerns teamwork. Relay races teach co-operation; nevertheless, injured pupils may feel left out. To sum up, I believe that taking part should be encouraged, provided that every pupil has a role they can do.