A smart stop, read closely
This week is a review, so you will use what you know on a new text. Start with the main idea and the writer’s view. Then check each statement: a fact can be checked, an opinion shows what a person thinks. Watch for persuasive words such as bound to, clearly, surely, nobody and worst: they push the reader towards one view. A balanced writer also gives the other side, often with on the other hand. Next, look for the grammar of Unit 5 in the text: which to comment on a whole idea, the future passive (will be replaced), the future continuous (will be waiting), and have something done (have the shelter rebuilt). Finally, summarise the text in two sentences in your own words.
| question to ask | what to look for |
|---|---|
| Is it a fact or an opinion? | Can it be checked? Is there a number or a source? |
| Is the wording fair? | bound to, clearly, surely, worst, nobody: persuasive words |
| Is there another side? | on the other hand, however, I must admit |
| Which Unit 5 grammar is used? | which comment, future passive, future continuous, have + object + past participle |
The smart bus stop: brilliant idea or expensive toy?
Next spring the shelter on Quarry Lane, which has stood there since 1985, will be replaced by a ‘smart’ bus stop. The council says that the new stop will have a screen that shows live arrival times, a charging point for phones and a sensor that counts passengers. According to the council’s leaflet, these figures will be used to plan better routes.
Supporters have been talking about the plan for weeks. Gulshan Tursunova, who travels to work by bus every day, says that she will be waiting less in the cold because she will see exactly when her bus arrives. Her neighbour adds that the screen is bound to be a huge success.
I am not so sure. First, nobody has explained who will pay when something goes wrong; the council admits that the screen will have to be repaired by an outside company, which will cost money every year. Second, the sensor collects data, and the leaflet does not say who will be allowed to see it. Surely residents deserve to know. Finally, this is clearly the worst moment to spend public money on gadgets while the road outside is full of holes.
On the other hand, I must admit that the old shelter has no lighting, and many passengers have had to wait in the dark. This time next winter, they may be sitting in a bright, warm shelter, charging their phones. Perhaps the answer is a compromise: have the shelter rebuilt with lighting and a roof, and test the screen at one stop first, before the council decides whether to copy it across the town.
Whatever happens, residents should have their say before the work begins.
| statement | type | why |
|---|---|---|
| The old shelter has no lighting. | fact | it can be checked by looking |
| The screen is bound to be a huge success. | opinion | bound to is a prediction, not a fact |
| This is clearly the worst moment to spend public money. | opinion with persuasive words | clearly and worst push the reader |
Reading detectives. Choose a short opinion piece from a newspaper or from a website that a family member selects. Highlight one fact in yellow, one opinion in green and one persuasive word in red. Then say aloud, in two sentences, what the writer thinks and whether the writer is fair. Swap texts with a partner and check each other’s colours.