Same event, two stories
Two reporters can write about the same event and give very different impressions. A fact can be checked: More than ninety bags were filled. An opinion is what someone thinks: It was chaos. To see a reporter’s attitude, look at four things. First, the headline. Second, the verbs and adjectives that are chosen: gathered sounds neutral, but swarmed sounds negative. Third, what is mentioned and what is left out. Fourth, who is quoted. A report that shows only one side may be biased. When you compare two reports, use linking words: Both reports mention … ; Report A says …, whereas Report B says … ; In contrast, …
| what to check | question to ask |
|---|---|
| headline | Is it neutral, or does it make us feel something? |
| verbs and adjectives | Are they positive, negative or neutral? |
| what is mentioned | Which facts are included? Which are missing? |
| who is quoted | Who is allowed to speak? Which opinion is shown? |
Report A. Headline: Park invaded by litter army. Hundreds of students swarmed into Riverside Park on Saturday morning, waving bin bags and shouting at passers-by. The noisy crowd blocked the main path for almost an hour, and several joggers had to leave by another route. The organisers said the aim was to collect rubbish, yet most of the young people seemed more interested in taking photos of each other. By midday the grass was covered with sandwich wrappers and empty cups. A shop owner said, ‘It was chaos.’
Report B. Headline: Students give Riverside Park a fresh start. About two hundred students gathered at the park on Saturday for a clean-up day. Wearing gloves and carrying recycling bags, they worked in small teams and filled more than ninety bags in three hours. Visitors stopped to thank them, and a few joined in. ‘We wanted to do something useful for the town,’ said one organiser. By lunchtime the paths were clear and the lawn looked tidier than it had in years.
| Report A | Report B | |
|---|---|---|
| verb for the students | swarmed | gathered |
| headline | Park invaded by litter army | Students give Riverside Park a fresh start |
| quote | ‘It was chaos.’ (a shop owner) | ‘We wanted to do something useful.’ (an organiser) |
| impression | noisy, unhelpful students | hard-working, helpful students |
Both reports describe the same Saturday at Riverside Park, but they give very different impressions. Report A uses negative words such as swarmed and invaded, whereas Report B says that the students gathered and worked in teams. In contrast with Report A, which quotes a shop owner, Report B quotes one of the organisers, so it shows mainly the students’ point of view. In my opinion, neither report is completely fair, because each one leaves out facts that are in the other.
Two headlines. Think of a small event at school or at home, for example a family dinner that went wrong. Write two headlines for it: one positive and one negative. Then write two sentences under each headline, using different verbs for the same action (gathered / swarmed, said / complained). Read them aloud. Your family decides which version sounds fairer.