Two witnesses, one bike rack
A witness statement says what a person saw, heard and did. A good statement gives the facts in order and does not guess. To compare two statements, look at each detail: time, place, people, clothes, numbers and what happened. Details that are different are inconsistent. Ask also: Could the witness see clearly? Did the witness see the event or only the result? Are there words like I think or probably that show a guess? Use the past continuous for the scene and the background (It was raining. I was reading.), and for an action that was interrupted by a short event (I was reading when the crash came). Use was / were going to for an intention that was not carried out: I was going to shout, but he had gone. Use the past simple for the finished events in order.
| use | example |
|---|---|
| scene and background | A woman was locking her scooter. |
| action interrupted by a short event | I was reading when a boy ran past. |
| intention not carried out | I was going to shout, but he was gone. |
| finished events in order | He hit the bike. It fell. He jumped on the bus. |
My name is Imani Okoro. I was sitting at the bus stop opposite the library at about ten past four, and I was reading a magazine. I looked up because a boy was running across the car park. He was wearing a bright yellow coat and carrying a large blue bag. He was trying to catch the number 12 bus, which was already pulling away. As he ran past the bike rack, his bag swung out and hit the end bike. That bike fell against the next one, and five bikes went down one after another. The boy did not stop. He jumped onto the bus and the doors closed. Nobody was hurt. A woman who was locking her scooter picked up two of the bikes. I think it was an accident, because the boy was not looking where he was going.
My name is Ben Castillo. At around twenty to five I was locking my bike at the rack outside the library, and I had my back to the road. I heard a loud crash, and when I turned round, four bikes were lying on the ground. A tall teenager in a green hoodie was walking away quickly with headphones on. I think he kicked the end bike because he was angry about something. I was going to shout at him, but he was already round the corner. The bikes did not look damaged. I helped to stand them up. The owner of the red bike will probably be upset.
| detail | Witness A | Witness B |
|---|---|---|
| time | about ten past four | around twenty to five |
| the person | a boy in a yellow coat with a bag | a tall teenager in a green hoodie |
| what happened | a bag hit the end bike | he kicked the end bike |
| bikes that fell | five | four |
| where was the witness looking? | at the boy, from across the road | away, until he heard the crash |
Two accounts, one event. Choose a small event that two people saw (for example, a glass falling in the kitchen). Each person writes a short statement of five sentences, without showing it to the other. Then compare: underline the details that are the same in green and the details that are different in red. Decide which statement is more reliable and say why.