GoalFollow and join a discussion about digital media: tell facts from opinions, balanced from biased, and agree or disagree politely.
New words
socialise · to meet and relax with friends or other peopleempathy · the ability to understand how someone else feelsaddiction · a condition in which you cannot stop doing or using somethinginteract · to talk or work with others so that you affect each otherevidence · information, such as a study or a number, that shows an idea is truebiased · showing only one side, often unfairly
Explanation
In a good discussion, ask three questions about each speaker: What is the opinion? What are the reasons? Is there evidence, such as a survey or a study? A balanced speaker gives both sides and uses careful words like many, some or often. A biased speaker gives only one side and uses extreme words like always, never, nobody or everybody. You can add emphasis with do or does in a positive sentence: I do agree that sleep matters. Your plan does make sense. To respond politely, link to what was said: That is a fair point, but … or Which is worth thinking about.
balanced speaker
biased speaker
some, many, often, usually
always, never, nobody, everybody
a study, a survey, a figure
“everyone knows”, “obviously”
both sides, then a view
one side only
I take your point, but …
That is nonsense!
Worked examples
Host
Today’s question: does messaging help or harm friendship? Ines, you first.
Ines
I do think messaging helps shy students. A survey at our school found that seventy per cent keep in touch with friends who live far away. However, it does worry me that some students message late at night and sleep less.
Tomas
Messaging is awful. Nobody talks to anybody any more. Everybody stares at a screen all day, and it ruins every friendship. It should be banned.
A school radio debate. Is the speaker balanced or biased?
job
phrase
agree
That is a fair point.
disagree politely
I take your point, but I am not convinced.
say something might be true
That could be true if students sleep enough.
comment on what was said
Which is worth thinking about.
Phrases for a polite discussion.
Say the discussion words aloud.
Class activity
Traffic-light debate. Make three cards for each player: green (I agree), red (I disagree) and yellow (I need evidence). The leader reads a statement, for example: “Online friends are as good as friends we meet in person.” After each speaker, everyone shows a card and one player explains the colour with a polite phrase from the lesson. Change the leader after every statement.
Practice
1
Listen. Is the speaker balanced or biased? Give one reason.
…
Biased. The speaker uses extreme words (everybody knows, nobody, all), gives no evidence and shows only one side.
2
Add do or does to make each sentence stronger. a) I like her idea, but it costs too much. b) My brother looks busy, but he wants to help.
a) I do like her idea, but it costs too much. b) My brother looks busy, but he does want to help.
3
Fact or opinion? a) A survey of 500 students found that 60 per cent check messages at night. b) Online friends are never as good as real friends. c) Many teachers use online forums to share lesson plans. d) Chatting is boring.
a) fact, with evidence; b) opinion (and biased: never); c) fact; d) opinion.
4
Match each phrase with its job. (a) “That is a fair point.” (b) “I am not convinced.” (c) “That could be true if people take breaks.” Jobs: (1) agree (2) disagree (3) suggest that something might be true.
a) 1; b) 2; c) 3.
5
Writing. Rustam says: “Messaging helps shy students make friends.” Hana says: “Messaging replaces face-to-face talk, so we learn less empathy.” Write a balanced summary of 50 to 70 words.
For example: Rustam and Hana disagree about messaging. Rustam argues that it helps shy students to make friends. Hana, however, thinks that it replaces talking face to face, so students learn less empathy. Both points are reasonable, and more evidence would help us to decide.