Is this writer fair?
A fact can be checked in a reliable source: the meadow covers about four hectares. An opinion is what someone believes or feels: it is the most beautiful place in town. Writers are biased when their feelings decide what they show and what they leave out. Signs of bias are: only one side is given, emotive words (selfish, disaster), sweeping words such as everyone, nobody, never and always, attacks on people instead of ideas, claims with no source, and pressure or threats. An objective text names its sources, uses numbers and gives both views fairly. Having an opinion is not a fault: a good opinion piece gives reasons and evidence, but a biased text hides the other side.
| sign of bias | example |
|---|---|
| sweeping word | Everyone knows …; The council never listens … |
| emotive word | disaster; selfish |
| attack on people | Only a selfish person could want … |
| pressure | … or you will regret it for the rest of your life! |
| no source | this plan will obviously be a disaster |
Plans for Mill Meadow
The town council is considering a proposal to turn Mill Meadow into a sports field. The meadow covers about four hectares and has been left uncut for twenty years. A survey carried out last summer by the local nature club recorded eleven species of butterfly there. The town’s youth football league, which has six hundred members, currently shares two pitches. Supporters of the plan say that more pitches would let more children play on Saturdays. Opponents say that the meadow is the last wild space near the school and that the butterflies would disappear. The council will hold a public meeting on 12 March, and residents can send comments until then.
Save Mill Meadow, now!
Only a selfish person could want to destroy Mill Meadow. Everyone knows that it is the most beautiful place in town, and the football lovers behind this plan simply do not care about nature. They say that children need pitches, but children have been playing happily in the park for generations. The council never listens to ordinary people, and this plan will obviously be a disaster. Once the butterflies are gone, they will be gone for ever. Sign our petition today, or you will regret it for the rest of your life!
| fair | biased |
|---|---|
| Some residents are worried about the plan. | Everybody is furious about the plan. |
| The meadow would be lost. | The meadow would be murdered. |
| A survey recorded eleven species. | The meadow is full of amazing creatures. |
| fact | opinion |
|---|---|
| The meadow covers about four hectares. | It is the most beautiful place in town. |
| The league has six hundred members. | This plan will obviously be a disaster. |
Town meeting. Three players take roles: a council planner, a football parent and a member of the nature club. Each has one minute to speak about a new car park, a new playground or another local plan. The others listen and write down one fact, one opinion and any sign of bias they hear. After the speeches, the listeners say which speaker was the most balanced and why.