Clean hands in history
In an active sentence the doer is the subject: Nurses clean the ward. In a passive sentence the person or thing affected is the subject: The ward is cleaned. The passive is the verb be + a past participle: is, am or are for the present, and was or were for the past. We use the passive when the doer is unknown, obvious or less important than the action, and it is very common in science and history writing. Add by + the doer only when it matters. Only verbs that can have an object can be passive: we say The patient was examined, but never The patient was arrived. Questions put be first: Was the ward cleaned? Were the instruments boiled?
| active (the doer is the subject) | passive (the receiver is the subject) |
|---|---|
| Doctors delivered the babies. | The babies were delivered by doctors. |
| Staff disinfect the rooms every day. | The rooms are disinfected every day. |
| Nobody understood his work. | His work was not understood. |
Clean hands: a lesson learned the hard way
In the 1840s, many women who gave birth in the great hospitals of Europe fell ill with a fever, and large numbers of them died. In 1847, a young doctor in Vienna, Ignaz Semmelweis, noticed a puzzling pattern. His hospital had two maternity wards. In the first, babies were delivered by doctors and medical students. In the second, they were delivered by midwives. Far more mothers died in the first ward than in the second.
Semmelweis searched for the cause. Then a colleague died after being cut by a knife during a post-mortem examination, and the colleague’s symptoms were the same as the mothers’ symptoms. Semmelweis realised that the doctors and students were walking straight from the post-mortem room to the maternity ward, and that something harmful was being carried on their hands.
He ordered every doctor to wash their hands in a strong cleaning liquid before touching a patient. The result was dramatic: within months the number of deaths in the first ward fell sharply.
Unfortunately, his idea was not welcomed. Many doctors were offended by the suggestion that they had caused harm, and his findings were ignored or rejected. Nobody yet knew that tiny living things, which we now call germs, cause infections. That was proved later by other scientists. Semmelweis died in 1865, long before his work was properly understood.
Today his lesson is taught in every medical school. Hands are washed before operations, instruments are cleaned at very high temperatures and hospital rooms are disinfected every day. Hand-washing is still one of the cheapest ways of preventing disease, in hospitals and at home.
| question | short answer |
|---|---|
| Was the idea welcomed? | No, it was not. |
| Are instruments cleaned today? | Yes, they are. |
| Were the findings accepted? | No, they were rejected. |
| Are patients with a dangerous disease kept apart from others? | Yes, they are. |
Passive quiz show. Prepare six cards about your school or home, each with an active sentence (for example: ‘Cooks prepare the lunch at noon.’). A player reads a card and the others say the passive sentence (‘The lunch is prepared at noon.’). The fastest correct answer wins the card. Swap and use past simple cards too.