Relative error
To compare different approximations of the same quantity the absolute error is enough, but to compare different quantities it is not. For example, an error of 2 km in 500 km versus an error of 1 mm in 12 cm — which is more accurate? So the relative error is introduced: if a is the approximate value of x, the relative error is the ratio of the absolute error to |a|, that is |x - a|/|a|. It is usually expressed in percent. The measurement with the smaller relative error is more accurate. If the absolute error is not known exactly but is at most h, the relative error does not exceed h/|a|.
Measuring a pencil as 10 cm with a 1 cm slip gives a relative error of 1/10 = 10 %. Measuring a road as 1000 m with a 1 m slip gives only 1/1000 = 0.1 %. The error is similar, the accuracy is very different.
A craftsperson judges accuracy relative to the size of the job, a scientist compares measurements of different quantities, and a production inspector gives faults as a percentage.
Guess the length of your notebook and of your classroom by eye, then check with a ruler or by steps. Which guess has the smaller relative error?
| Measurement | Relative error |
|---|---|
| 20 ± 0.5 cm | 0.5/20 = 2.5 % |
| 400 ± 2 km | 2/400 = 0.5 % |
“The more accurate measurement”: groups compare two measurement results (a length, a mass) by relative error and prove which is more accurate.