The elements of a crime
A crime is a guilty, socially dangerous act (action or omission) prohibited by the Criminal Code under threat of punishment. Its signs are social danger, unlawfulness, guilt and punishability. The composition of a crime has four elements: the object (the social relation protected, such as life or property), the objective side (the act itself and its consequence), the subject (a sane natural person who has reached the set age) and the subjective side (fault, motive, purpose); if one is missing there is no crime. Fault has two forms: intent (the person understood the danger of the act and wanted the result — direct intent — or consciously allowed it — indirect intent) and negligence (overconfidence or carelessness). In some cases an act that looks like a crime from outside is not a crime: an insignificant act, necessary defence, extreme necessity, causing harm while detaining an offender, carrying out an order, justified risk, and physical or mental coercion.
| Element | Content |
|---|---|
| Object | The protected social relation |
| Objective side | The act and its consequence |
| Subject | A sane individual of the set age |
| Subjective side | Guilt, motive, purpose |
When something happened at school, the teacher asked four questions: what happened, who was involved, what was the result, and was it on purpose or by accident. Different answers led to different conclusions.
Investigators study an event by breaking it into parts, judges and defence lawyers check that each part is proved, and school disciplinary panels establish the cause of an incident.
Take an invented small mishap (for example, a spilled cup) and answer the same four questions in writing.
| Element | Botir’s case |
|---|---|
| Object | Another’s property |
| Objective side | Secret taking |
| Subject | Sane Botir of the age of criminal liability |
| Subjective side | Intent and purpose of appropriation |
| Intent | Direct intent; Indirect intent |
|---|---|
| Negligence | Self-confidence; Carelessness |
“Composition puzzle”: the teacher splits one criminal case into four cards (object, objective side, subject, subjective side) and groups place the cards in the right places.