AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
Story of the WeekGrade 10 · Week 2

Are dialect words mistakes?

🎯 Mission: Is the post “dialect words are mistakes, real language is only the literary one” true?

Monday

JasurA new claim arrived. A blogger’s post: “Dialect words are just mistakes. Real Uzbek is only the literary language.” 👀
MalikaWe covered this in the Uzbek lesson. The is the whole linguistic wealth of a people: the literary language, folk dialects, elements of ordinary conversation and jargons.
ZarinaThe is the processed, normalised highest form of the national language. Everyone follows its norms of spelling, pronunciation, word use and grammar.
AnvarA dialect stands outside those norms, but it can enrich the literary language. So calling it a “mistake” may be wrong.
Let’s split the post into two parts: “the literary language has norms” and “dialect words are mistakes”. We check each one separately.
Uzbek language

Lock 1: The second claim: dialects

Your turn: What belongs to the national language?

🔑 Key: The national language includes both the literary language and folk dialects; the literary language is its normalised form.

ZarinaIn literature we read an excerpt from the dastan “Rustamxon”. According to the textbook it was written down from a bard in 1937. (I won’t retell it, read it in the book!)
AnvarSo the dastan lived in oral form through the generations and then moved into written form.
MalikaThe literary language also has two forms: oral (lecture, speech, conversation) and written (book, document, article). Which one we pick depends on the purpose of communication.
JasurBut the written form plays the main role in making the norms stable.
This confirms the first part of the post: the literary language has norms, and they are fixed in written texts.
Literature

Lock 2: Oral and written forms

Your turn: Which form plays the main role in stabilising literary norms?

🔑 Key: The literary language has norms, kept stable mainly through the written form, so that part of the post is true.

AnvarLet’s use logic from maths. A is a declarative sentence that is true or false. “The dialect is beautiful” is an opinion, not a statement.
Malikap: “The literary language has norms” is true (T). q: “Dialect words are mistakes” is false (F). The post says p ∧ q, a .
ZarinaA conjunction is true only when both parts are true. We have T and F, so p ∧ q is false.
JasurAnd negation? ¬(p ∧ q) ≡ ¬p ∨ ¬q, one of de Morgan’s laws. So the whole post is not true: at least one of its parts must fail, and q does.
Logic shows us the “half-true” case clearly: one part true, one part false.
Mathematics

Lock 3: Statements and logic

Your turn: p is true, q is false. What is the value of p ∧ q?

🔑 Key: A conjunction (p ∧ q) with one false part is false as a whole; so a “two-part” post cannot be fully true.

Tuesday

AzizA classmate says a ball thrown upward stops at the top, so gravity “switches off” there. Is that true?
AnvarWe test it in Excel. B1 = 10 (initial speed, m/s), B2 = 10 (g). Height: =$B$1*A3-$B$2*A3^2/2, with time in column A from 0 to 2 s in steps of 0.5.
ZarinaResult: 0; 3.75; 5; 3.75; 0 metres. I drew a “scatter with smooth lines” chart: the curve peaks at t = 1 s.
MalikaThe speed is v = 10 − 10t. At t = 1 s v = 0, but at t = 0.9 s it is +1 m/s and at t = 1.1 s it is −1 m/s. The speed changes by 10 m/s every second, so gravity still acts at the top.
So Aziz’s classmate is half right: the speed is zero, but only for an instant. That was a side check; our main claim is about language.
ComputingPhysics

Lock 4: Aziz draws a graph

Your turn: v₀ = 10 m/s, g = 10 m/s². What is the height at t = 0.8 s (h = v₀t − gt²/2)?

ZarinaOur club page will appear in English too. In the English lesson we covered the Passive Voice: be + past participle.
AnvarWhen do we use it? When the action or its result matters more than who did it: The claim was shared by thousands of people.
MalikaTenses: Present — Cotton is grown in many regions. Past — The bridge was built in 1998. Future — The report will be published tomorrow.
JasurIt works with modals too: The claim must be checked. I like this one most — it’s our motto!
Let that be the first sentence of the report: The post was checked by our club.
English

Lock 5: The report in the passive

Your turn: Build the sentence: tap the words in order.

Tap the words in order to build the sentence

Theclaimmustbechecked.

Wednesday

AzizA classmate said living things are 98 percent carbon. Is that so?
ZarinaNo, we need to read carefully! The textbook says the macroelements C, O, H and N together make about 98 percent. Not carbon alone.
AnvarMicroelements are below 0.001 percent: iodine, copper, cobalt, fluorine, zinc. For example, iron carries oxygen in haemoglobin.
MalikaAt the molecular level carbon is important because it forms long chains. ATP is the cell’s energy “currency”.
This applies to our post too: one true part does not make the whole statement true.
Biology

Lock 6: What does “98 percent” mean?

Your turn: Which elements does the textbook’s “98 percent” refer to?

🔑 Key: Read the figure in full: “C, O, H, N together ≈ 98%” does not mean carbon alone is 98%: one true part does not make the whole statement true.

AnvarIt is like that in chemistry too: the formula C₂H₆O fits two substances, ethanol and dimethyl ether. The formula is the same, the properties differ.
MalikaSuch substances are and the phenomenon is isomerism. The order of atoms (the structure) differs, so the properties differ too.
ZarinaWords are the same: change the order of the same words and the meaning changes. In a report we must check word order too.
JasurChain isomerism: C₄H₁₀ has two isomers, n-butane and 2-methylpropane; C₅H₁₂ has three.
A formula is not everything yet. In the same way, a single word is not yet the meaning.
Chemistry (Organic chemistry)

Lock 7: Same letters, different order

Your turn: How many chain isomers does C₅H₁₂ have?

Thursday

Class teacherFrom the state and law lesson: there is no “world government” above states. States create the norms themselves by agreement.
AnvarThe main sources are the international treaty (a written agreement) and international custom (long practice accepted as legally binding).
ZarinaSo a source shows where something comes from and what it rests on. We too ask for the post’s source: who said “dialect words are mistakes”, and on which rule?
MalikaThe history of religions lesson covered scholars of medieval Central Asia: al-Khwarizmi, al-Farabi, al-Biruni and Ibn Sina worked in mathematics, astronomy, medicine and philosophy.
Class teacherHistorians consider that in that period science and religion largely complemented each other. This is only a historical fact from the textbook, not a judgement of beliefs.
State and lawHistory of world religions

Lock 8: Treaties and the learning of the past

Your turn: What are the main sources of international law?

JasurA side post for today: “The leap year is pointless, people just invented it.”
ZarinaFrom geography: the Earth goes round the Sun in about 365 days 6 hours. That is 6 extra hours a year.
AnvarIn 4 years that is 4 · 6 = 24 hours, one full day. That is why a day is added every fourth year.
MalikaAlso: the Moon is about 384 thousand km away and causes the tides in the oceans. And sunlight is the main energy for weather and life.
So that post is false: the leap year comes from a calculation, not a random invention.
Geography (Applied geography)

Lock 9: The Moon, the Sun and the leap year

Your turn: The year is 365 days 6 hours long. How many extra hours add up in 4 years?

AnvarWorld history: science advanced fast in 1918–1939. Insulin was isolated in 1921–1922 and penicillin was discovered in 1928.
ZarinaIn 1927 sound film appeared and the BBC became a public corporation. In 1938 the fission of the uranium nucleus was discovered.
JasurOne post says: “Penicillin was discovered before sound film.” We check: 1928 and 1927.
Malika1927 < 1928, so the film came first. The post is false. We compare a date with an exact source, not with a feeling about what is “more important”.
And when writing a date we give both the year and the event exactly.
World history

Lock 10: When was it discovered?

Your turn: Which happened first?

Friday

AnvarHistory of Uzbekistan: in Petrograd power was seized on the night of 24–25 October 1917 (old style) and a Council of People’s Commissars was formed.
ZarinaIn the new style this is 6–7 November. Add 13 days to 25 October: 38 − 31 = 7 November.
MalikaIn Turkestan Soviet power was established by force and local forces reacted in different ways. We only list the facts of the textbook.
JasurIn the Russian lesson, antonyms: «щедрый — жадный», «подниматься — спускаться». In the report we are careful with words like «всегда — никогда».
Because for a post that says “never” or “always”, a single counterexample is enough.
History of UzbekistanRussian language

Lock 11: Old style, new style; antonyms

Your turn: Which word is the antonym of «подниматься»?

AnvarLet’s gather the keys. 🔑1: the national language includes dialects. 🔑2: the literary language has norms, kept stable by the written form. 🔑3: if one part of p ∧ q is false, the whole statement is not true.
ZarinaThe post says “the literary language has norms” — true. But “dialect words are mistakes” — false. If we said FALSE we would deny the true part.
MalikaSo the verdict is MISLEADING: a false conclusion is hidden behind a true part.
JasurAnd a note: a dialect is not a “mistake”, but official documents and school writing need the literary norm.
Agreed. The deciding keys are 1 and 3. The second key explains the true part of the post.
Uzbek languageMathematics

Lock 12: Verdict: misleading

Your turn: Which keys decided the verdict (MISLEADING)?

A whole week in one story!

This story brought together 14 subjects.

MathematicsUzbek languageEnglishComputingLiteratureBiologyState and lawHistory of world religionsPhysicsGeography (Applied geography)World historyChemistry (Organic chemistry)History of UzbekistanRussian language

0 / 15 stars

Team report

Are dialect words mistakes? Verdict: MISLEADING

Claim: “Dialect words are mistakes; real Uzbek is only the literary language.” Verdict: MISLEADING. Evidence: 1) the national language includes both the literary language and dialects; 2) the literary language has norms, so that part of the claim is true; 3) logic: in “p ∧ q” one false part makes the whole statement untrue. What readers can do: split a claim into parts and check each one separately.

— 10-B team

Keys found

  1. The national language includes both the literary language and folk dialects; the literary language is its normalised form.
  2. The literary language has norms, kept stable mainly through the written form, so that part of the post is true.
  3. A conjunction (p ∧ q) with one false part is false as a whole; so a “two-part” post cannot be fully true.
  4. Read the figure in full: “C, O, H, N together ≈ 98%” does not mean carbon alone is 98%: one true part does not make the whole statement true.

Star questions

  1. p is false, q is true. What is p ∨ q?

  2. Which sentence is in the passive?

  3. Think: if the post had only said “the literary language has norms”, what would the verdict be?

Lessons in this story