AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
Story of the WeekGrade 10 · Week 3

“Sugar-free”: carbohydrate-free?

🎯 Mission: Do sugar-free biscuits really contain no carbohydrates at all?

Monday

JasurNew claim: a biscuit advert is going round the class chat: “Sugar-free biscuits: zero carbohydrates! No energy at all!” 🍪
ZarinaFrom the Uzbek lesson: there are five main styles: colloquial, publicistic, artistic, scientific and official. An advert is written to persuade, so it leans on emotion.
AnvarA is a variety of language adapted to its purpose. Our report will be in the scientific style: precise, with numbers, checkable.
MalikaThe advert’s slogan, “sugar-free”, is short and bright. But a slogan is not evidence: we turn it into a logical statement, “if it is sugar-free, it has no carbohydrates”, and check that.
Two questions: what does “sugar-free” mean, and what is a “carbohydrate”? They may not be the same thing.
Uzbek language

Lock 1: The style of an advert

Your turn: Which style is an advert close to, and what is it written for?

🔑 Key: An advert slogan is written to persuade and is not evidence; to check it we turn it into an exact statement.

AnvarThe slogan is p ⇒ q. p: “the biscuit is sugar-free”, q: “the biscuit has no carbohydrates”. An is false in exactly one case: p true and q false.
ZarinaSo one is enough to refute it: a sugar-free biscuit that has carbohydrates.
MalikaBe careful: q ⇒ p, “if there are no carbohydrates, it is sugar-free”, is the . It may be true, but it is not equivalent to the original.
JasurThe equivalent one is the : ¬q ⇒ ¬p, “if it has carbohydrates, it is not sugar-free”. But first we look for a counterexample.
We can find the counterexample in biology: what are carbohydrates made of?
Mathematics

Lock 2: If … then …

Your turn: When is p ⇒ q false?

🔑 Key: One counterexample (p true, q false) is enough to refute “if p, then q”.

ZarinaThe biology lesson: carbohydrates fall into three groups: monosaccharides (glucose), disaccharides (sucrose) and polysaccharides (starch, glycogen, cellulose).
AnvarStarch is a built from many glucose units; it is not sweet and does not dissolve in water, but it is a carbohydrate! It is the reserve substance in plants.
MalikaFlour and rice are sources of starch. A sugar-free biscuit made from flour has carbohydrates. Counterexample found!
JasurAlso: are fats and an energy source: 1 g of fat gives about 38.9 kJ. So “no energy” is doubtful too.
ZarinaProteins too: high temperature destroys the natural shape of a protein, ; that is why the white of a boiled egg turns solid. In DNA A = T and G = C.
So “sugar-free” is not “carbohydrate-free”. Starch proves it.
Biology

Lock 3: Carbohydrate or sugar?

Your turn: Which group does starch belong to?

🔑 Key: Starch is a polysaccharide that is not sweet but is a carbohydrate; so “sugar-free” does not mean “carbohydrate-free”.

Wednesday

AnvarThe biscuit packet’s label (an imaginary one we made up). Per 100 g: carbohydrates 62 g (sugars 0 g), fat 20 g, protein 8 g. I put it on a sheet called “Label”.
ZarinaOn the calculation sheet we refer to a cell on another sheet: =Label!B2. The sheet name, then an exclamation mark, then the address.
JasurEnergy: carbohydrate 62 g · 17 kJ/g and fat 20 g · 38.9 kJ/g. =SUMPRODUCT(B2:B3;C2:C3) gives the sum of products. Result: 1054 + 778 = 1832 kJ.
MalikaA note: this is only for our imaginary label. Real products have other numbers. The point is that “62 g of carbohydrate” is not “zero carbohydrate”.
And before updating links in a foreign file we are careful: we allow it only for files we trust.
Computing

Lock 4: The label table

Your turn: How do you refer to cell B2 on the sheet “Label”?

🔑 Key: Our imaginary label: 62 g of carbohydrate per 100 g with 0 g of sugars, so a “sugar-free” product can still contain carbohydrate.

MalikaThe chemistry lesson: by composition organic compounds form three groups: hydrocarbons (only C and H), oxygen-containing (C, H, O) and nitrogen-containing (C, H, N, often O too).
AnvarStarch and fat consist of C, H, O, so they are oxygen-containing. Protein also has nitrogen.
ZarinaTypes of reactions: substitution (CH₄ + Cl₂ → CH₃Cl + HCl), addition (CH₂=CH₂ + Br₂ → CH₂Br–CH₂Br) and elimination (C₂H₅OH → CH₂=CH₂ + H₂O).
JasurIn addition a double bond opens; in elimination a small molecule (for example water) splits off.
Classifying is a good habit for checking: first find the group, then draw the conclusion.
Chemistry (Organic chemistry)

Lock 5: Classification by composition

Your turn: What type of reaction is CH₂=CH₂ + Br₂ → CH₂Br–CH₂Br?

AzizHey, the small wheel on my bike turns fast. Is it true that a smaller wheel always turns faster?
AnvarIn a belt or friction drive with no slipping, the linear speeds at the rims are equal: ω₁R₁ = ω₂R₂. A smaller radius means a bigger ω. That is true.
ZarinaWith a chain it is the teeth: N₁ν₁ = N₂ν₂. The front sprocket has 48 teeth, the rear one 16. ν₂ = 48 : 16 · ν₁ = 3ν₁: one turn of the pedals gives 3 turns of the rear wheel.
JasurA carousel turns non-uniformly: in 4 s its angular speed grew from 0 to 1.2 rad/s. The angular acceleration is ε = Δω/Δt = 1.2 : 4 = 0.3 rad/s².
So “the smaller wheel turns faster” is true, with a condition: at the same rim speed. This side check is TRUE.
Physics

Lock 6: The bicycle and the carousel

Your turn: The front sprocket has 48 teeth and the rear one 16. How many times does the rear wheel turn per one pedal turn?

Thursday

JasurA small post: “The continents don’t move; they stand in place for ever.”
ZarinaFrom geography: the lithosphere is split into large plates that move over the asthenosphere at a few centimetres per year.
AnvarLet’s calculate: 3 cm a year · 1,000,000 years = 3,000,000 cm = 30 km. Thirty km in a million years looks small, but in geological time it is a lot.
MalikaWhere plates collide or pull apart, earthquakes and volcanoes are frequent: the Pacific “Ring of Fire” and the Alpine–Himalayan belt. Uzbekistan lies in the Alpine–Himalayan belt too, so noticeable earthquakes sometimes happen.
The post is wrong: continents move very slowly, but they move. For safety questions we follow the instructions of the local services.
Geography (Applied geography)

Lock 7: How fast do plates move?

Your turn: A plate moves 2 cm a year. How many km does it move in 5 million years?

AnvarFrom the state and law lesson: the UN Charter was signed in San Francisco on 26 June 1945 and entered into force on 24 October. That is why 24 October is UN Day.
ZarinaToday 193 states are members of the UN; Uzbekistan joined on 2 March 1992; the headquarters is in New York. There were 51 original members.
JasurA post on world history: “Britain declared war on Germany the very day Poland was invaded.”
MalikaLet’s check: Germany invaded Poland on 1 September 1939 and Britain declared war on 3 September. Two days apart. The post is inaccurate.
Another good habit: we check “the very same day” against dates.
State and lawWorld history

Lock 8: The UN and a date check

Your turn: Germany invaded Poland on 1 September. When did Britain declare war?

AnvarHistory of Uzbekistan: the Turkestan Autonomy was proclaimed. One post says: “It was proclaimed in Tashkent.”
ZarinaThe textbook says: the Fourth Extraordinary All-Turkestan Muslim Congress met in Kokand on 26–28 November 1917 and on the night of 27 November declared the region autonomous.
MalikaThe government was formed on 28 November: it published newspapers, prepared a constitution and announced an armed force and a loan. The Autonomy was ended in February 1918, but the textbook calls it a symbol of the peoples’ aspiration to statehood.
JasurSo the post is wrong: the city was Kokand, not Tashkent. The date matters too: the night of 27 November.
For a historical claim we check three things: place, date and source.
History of Uzbekistan

Lock 9: Kokand and the Autonomy

Your turn: In which city was the Turkestan Autonomy proclaimed?

ZarinaThe English lesson: Past Simple and Past Perfect. Ulugh Beg built an observatory in Samarkand in the 1420s. By the time he built it, he had already studied astronomy for years.
AnvarPast Perfect shows what happened first: By the time we opened the packet, the advert had already promised “zero carbs”.
MalikaFrom literature: in the analysis of the characters of the dastan “Rustamxon”, every opinion rests on the text. We too say “the textbook says so”, not “I think so”, about a character.
JasurA character analysis is a fact-check too: evidence first, judgement after. We don’t retell the plot, read the book!
And we recognise a word’s class by its ending: -tion, -ment nouns; -ize verbs; -ful adjectives.
EnglishLiterature

Lock 10: Famous people and evidence

Your turn: Which is right? By the time he built it, he ___ already studied astronomy.

JasurIn the Russian lesson, paronyms: «одеть» means to dress someone, «надеть» means to put something on oneself.
ZarinaRight: «Я надел куртку», but «Я одел брата». They sound alike but differ in meaning.
AnvarHomonyms have the same spelling and sound but unrelated meanings: «лук» the vegetable and «лук» the weapon. This is not a polysemantic word!
MalikaThe advert’s «без сахара» can be understood in two ways: “no added sugar” or “no sugar at all”. That is why we look at a dictionary and the label.
A third key: we don’t pass a verdict without pinning down the meaning of the word.
Russian language

Lock 11: «Одеть» or «надеть»?

Your turn: Which sentence is correct?

🔑 Key: If a word’s meaning is not pinned down, the claim is vague too: “sugar-free” can be read in two ways, so we look at the number on the label.

AnvarLet’s gather the keys. 🔑1: an advert slogan is not evidence. 🔑2: one counterexample is enough to refute “if sugar-free, then carbohydrate-free”. 🔑3: starch is a polysaccharide, so a carbohydrate even if it is not sweet. 🔑4: 62 g of carbohydrate on the label.
ZarinaWhat “sugar-free” means was not clear. But “zero carbohydrate” is an exact statement and can be checked.
MalikaThere is a counterexample, so the claim is false. And it is not only about our imaginary label: starchy foods always contain carbohydrates.
The verdict is FALSE. The deciding keys are 2 and 3; key 4 confirms it with a number.
JasurFor questions about a special diet we turn to a doctor or dietitian. We only checked the advert’s statement.
BiologyMathematics

Lock 12: Verdict: false

Your turn: Which two keys decided the verdict?

A whole week in one story!

This story brought together 13 subjects.

MathematicsUzbek languageEnglishComputingLiteratureBiologyState and lawPhysicsGeography (Applied geography)World historyChemistry (Organic chemistry)History of UzbekistanRussian language

0 / 15 stars

Team report

Is a “sugar-free” biscuit carbohydrate-free? Verdict: FALSE

Claim: “Sugar-free biscuits contain zero carbohydrates.” Verdict: FALSE. Evidence: 1) one counterexample is enough to refute “if p, then q”; 2) starch is a polysaccharide that is not sweet but is a carbohydrate, and flour and rice contain a lot of it; 3) our imaginary label shows 62 g of carbohydrate per 100 g with 0 g of sugars. What readers can do: read the numbers on the label, not the slogan, and ask a doctor about a special diet.

— 10-B team

Keys found

  1. An advert slogan is written to persuade and is not evidence; to check it we turn it into an exact statement.
  2. One counterexample (p true, q false) is enough to refute “if p, then q”.
  3. Starch is a polysaccharide that is not sweet but is a carbohydrate; so “sugar-free” does not mean “carbohydrate-free”.
  4. Our imaginary label: 62 g of carbohydrate per 100 g with 0 g of sugars, so a “sugar-free” product can still contain carbohydrate.
  5. If a word’s meaning is not pinned down, the claim is vague too: “sugar-free” can be read in two ways, so we look at the number on the label.

Star questions

  1. What is ¬q ⇒ ¬p for p ⇒ q?

  2. If A = 30 % in DNA, what is G?

  3. Think: if the label had said 0 g of carbohydrate, what might the verdict have been?

Lessons in this story