AdvertisementYour brand could be hereYour brand hereOn every Darslab page · students, parents and teachersinfo@darslab.comAsk for pricesPricesinfo@darslab.com
Story of the WeekGrade 10 · Week 1

The Fact-check club: the first claim

🎯 Mission: Does a ball tossed straight up by a walking person land behind them?

Monday

Class teacherGood day, 10-B! Welcome to Grade 10. This year the school opens a “Fact-check” club, and you four will run it.
Class teacherThe rule is simple: we take a claim that is going round the chats, check it with evidence and publish a verdict: TRUE, FALSE, MISLEADING or CAN’T TELL YET.
AnvarHow do we write the report? Grammar teaches correct writing, but what is for?
Malika makes correct speech accurate and effective for the . For our report the style is precise, calm and without exaggeration.
ZarinaThe literature lesson said it too: enriches our inner world. But a report needs facts, not poetic exaggeration.
I suggest four questions for every report: who is saying it? what is the evidence? can we test it? what do reliable sources say?
Uzbek languageLiterature

Lock 1: The Fact-check club opens

Your turn: What does stylistics teach?

JasurI collected 30 posts from last week’s class chat. 18 are about science, 14 are about health.
Anvar18 + 14 = 32, but there are only 30 posts! Where is the mistake?
MalikaNo mistake: 6 posts belong to both, so they are in the . They were counted twice. n(A ∪ B) = n(A) + n(B) − n(A ∩ B).
ZarinaSo 18 + 14 − 6 = 26 posts are about science or health. The other 30 − 26 = 4 are in the : they are about neither.
Let’s take our first claim from the science posts — it is about physics.
Mathematics

Lock 2: Sorting posts into sets

Your turn: Of the 18 science posts, 6 are also about health. How many posts are about science only?

Tuesday

JasurHere is the claim: “If a walking person throws a ball straight up, it lands behind them, because the person moves on while the ball is in the air.” Lots of people shared it! 😮
ZarinaFirst question: who is saying it? The author is unknown and no measurements are shown.
AnvarAs in physics: first a , then an experiment. Our hypothesis: the ball comes back down into the hand.
MalikaIn the experiment we reduce outside influences: a windless school hall, an even pace. This is : we keep what matters and drop the rest.
We test it two ways: an experiment and a calculation. If both agree, our confidence grows.
Physics

Lock 3: The first claim

Your turn: When does a hypothesis in physics become a law?

🔑 Key: In physics a claim is a hypothesis and is tested by experiment; many people believing it is not evidence.

MalikaPhysics has the : the two motions of a body do not interfere, and the real motion is their sum.
AnvarI walk steadily at 1.5 m/s. When the ball leaves my hand it keeps that horizontal speed.
ZarinaLet the upward speed be 4 m/s. The time up and down is 2 · 4 : 10 = 0.8 s (g ≈ 10 m/s²). The ball rises 4² : 20 = 0.8 m.
JasurIn 0.8 s I walk 1.5 · 0.8 = 1.2 m. The ball also travels exactly 1.2 m horizontally!
MalikaSo relative to me the ball only goes up and down. Relative to the ground its path is a curve. The is made of both motions.
But if I speed up or turn while the ball is in the air, the horizontal speed changes. Let’s note that condition too.
Physics

Lock 4: Two independent motions

Your turn: A person walks at a steady 2 m/s; the ball is in the air 0.8 s. How far does it travel horizontally over the ground?

🔑 Key: Principle of independence: while walking steadily the ball keeps the person’s horizontal speed, so it comes back to the hand.

Wednesday

AnvarWe did the experiment 10 times and I typed the results into Excel. The walking speed is in cell B1: 1.5.
ZarinaColumn A holds the time in the air. In C2 the formula is =A2*$B$1, the distance covered.
JasurWhy $B$1 and not B1? If I copy the formula down, B1 would slide to B2 as well!
MalikaRight: A2 is a , it shifts. $B$1 is an : the dollar signs fix the column and the row.
AnvarResult: when I walked steadily, the ball landed in my hand in all 9 of 9 tosses. In the tenth I sped up — the ball landed 25 cm behind.
Let’s be careful: 10 tosses is a small sample. This is “our test”, not a law for the whole world.
Computing

Lock 5: Into the spreadsheet

Your turn: If we copy the formula =A2*$B$1 into C3, what does it become?

🔑 Key: Our test: with steady walking the ball landed in the hand in 9 of 9 tosses; when speeding up it landed 25 cm behind.

Class teacherAn example from the history of chemistry: in the early 1800s scientists believed that organic substances form only in living things, through a special “vital force”.
ZarinaThen an organic substance was made in a laboratory without any living thing, and the idea was disproved. Everyone believing something is not evidence; an experiment is.
Anvar is the chemistry of carbon compounds. By Butlerov’s theory atoms join in a definite order according to their valences; carbon is tetravalent.
MalikaIn methane CH₄ hydrogen is +1, four hydrogens give +4. The molecule is neutral, so the of carbon is −4.
So even a long-held “everyone knows” can be overturned by an experiment. That is the idea of our club.
Chemistry (Organic chemistry)

Lock 6: “Everyone says so”

Your turn: What is the oxidation state of carbon in CH₄?

🔑 Key: Even a popular belief can be overturned by an experiment: the “vital force” idea was disproved by laboratory synthesis.

AzizHey, my toy robot walks, makes sounds and even says “hello”. Is it alive?
ZarinaBy the biology lesson, the properties of life are cellular structure, metabolism, growth, reproduction, heredity, irritability and .
AnvarSome features occur in non-living nature too: a crystal grows in a salt solution and a candle releases energy as it burns. But they do not reproduce through hereditary information.
MalikaThe robot has no cells, it does not reproduce and it has no homeostasis. So it is not alive, even if it looks “lifelike”.
Another rule: looking similar is not evidence, we check against the definition.
Biology

Lock 7: Is the robot alive?

Your turn: Which of these is not a property of life?

ZarinaThe geography lesson: this science studies the , the single natural system where the lithosphere, hydrosphere, atmosphere and biosphere meet.
JasurClaims were checked in the history of the science too. In antiquity Eratosthenes tried to calculate the size of the Earth.
AnvarAnd that the Earth is round was confirmed in practice by the expedition begun by Magellan (1519–1522): the ship sailed all the way round.
MalikaSo geography has too: observation, measuring, comparing and mapping.
The most reliable evidence is a result that can be measured again. We will show our test to others too.
Geography (Applied geography)

Lock 8: The scholar who measured the Earth

Your turn: Which expedition confirmed in practice that the Earth is round?

Thursday

AnvarHistory homework: the February Revolution of 1917 is dated 27 February in the book and 12 March on the internet. Did somebody make a mistake?
MalikaNo! 27 February is the old style and 12 March the new style. Both are right, because the calendars differ by 13 days.
JasurChange came to Turkestan too: after the February Revolution the Provisional Government took power and the governor-general was removed.
ZarinaAnother date to verify from world history: the Treaty of Versailles was signed on 28 June 1919; the League of Nations was set up to keep the peace.
A rule: when we write a date we add the calendar style, for example “27 February (old style)”.
World historyHistory of Uzbekistan

Lock 9: One event, two dates

Your turn: 27 February (old style) is which date in the new style?

Class teacherFrom the state and law lesson: the Constitution is the basis of the common rules between person, society and state. It was adopted in a nationwide referendum on 30 April 2023.
Zarina means knowing the law and actually following it. A person who knows the law well but breaks it has a low legal culture.
MalikaOur club rule: we name our sources in the report and write nothing that could harm anyone.
AnvarThe history of religions lesson covered the functions of religion in society: shaping a worldview, offering consolation, uniting people. Freedom of conscience is guaranteed in Uzbekistan.
Class teacherThat is why the club does not check beliefs: that is not a fact-check topic. We only use the neutral facts in the textbook.
State and lawHistory of world religions

Lock 10: Rules and respect

Your turn: A person knows the law well but breaks it. What does this show?

Friday

ZarinaIn the Russian lesson we covered the (polysemantic word). «Ключ» means a door key, a spring of water and a wrench, so it is polysemantic.
AnvarMonosemantic words are often terms. A fact-check needs precise words too: «доказательство» (evidence), «проверка» (checking).
MalikaThere are too: in the row «смелый — храбрый — отважный» the word «отважный» is the strongest praise. In the report we choose words by shade of meaning.
ZarinaFor the English description: Uzbekistan is a landlocked country; it is bordered by five countries. It has no coast.
And our club’s «ключ» is a key: we write evidence as “🔑 Key”.
Russian languageEnglish

Lock 11: «Ключ», a word with many meanings

Your turn: What kind of word is «ключ»?

AnvarLet’s gather the keys. 🔑1: we don’t believe, we test. 🔑2: principle of independence: when walking steadily the ball moves forward with the person at the same speed. 🔑3: our test: 9 tosses, 9 times in the hand.
MalikaThe claim says in general that “the ball lands behind”. For steady walking that is wrong. It could happen only if we speed up or turn.
ZarinaThen isn’t it “MISLEADING”? A part of it is right.
MalikaThe claim also gives the wrong reason: “the person moves on”, but the ball moves on with them. So the verdict is FALSE, and we put the condition in a note.
Agreed: verdict FALSE. The deciding keys are the principle and our test.
JasurWe published the report 📋 New claim next week!
Physics

Lock 12: The verdict

Your turn: Which two keys decided the verdict?

A whole week in one story!

This story brought together 14 subjects.

MathematicsUzbek languageEnglishComputingLiteratureBiologyState and lawHistory of world religionsPhysicsGeography (Applied geography)World historyChemistry (Organic chemistry)History of UzbekistanRussian language

0 / 15 stars

Team report

Does a ball tossed up land behind us? Verdict: FALSE

Claim: if you toss a ball straight up while walking, it lands behind you. Verdict: FALSE. Evidence: 1) by the principle of independence the ball keeps its forward speed; 2) calculation: in 0.8 s you walk 1.2 m at 1.5 m/s and the ball travels the same; 3) our test: in 9 of 9 steady tosses the ball landed in the hand, and when we sped up it landed 25 cm behind. What readers can do: test a video themselves before sharing it.

— 10-B team

Keys found

  1. In physics a claim is a hypothesis and is tested by experiment; many people believing it is not evidence.
  2. Principle of independence: while walking steadily the ball keeps the person’s horizontal speed, so it comes back to the hand.
  3. Our test: with steady walking the ball landed in the hand in 9 of 9 tosses; when speeding up it landed 25 cm behind.
  4. Even a popular belief can be overturned by an experiment: the “vital force” idea was disproved by laboratory synthesis.

Star questions

  1. Set A has 12 elements, B has 9 and the intersection has 4. What is n(A ∪ B)?

  2. Which date is written well?

  3. Think: if the test had been done only once, what could the verdict have been?

Lessons in this story