Week 5 · Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world · 3 lessons
3
Check with two more
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9DW.01
GoalCheck a claim against two other trusted sources and tell satire from lies.
New words
trusted source · a source with a known author, a good record and evidencesatire · writing that makes fun of something and is meant as a joke, not as newsmisinformation · false information that spreads, whether or not the sender meant harmcross-check · to compare a claim with other sources
Explanation
When a claim matters, do not rely on one page. Open a new tab or ask: do two other trusted sources say the same? Use different kinds, for example a library book, a school or museum, a reliable news organisation and an official body. If they disagree, look for the original source. Satire is different from lies. A satirical page invents silly news on purpose to make people laugh or think, and it says so, often in its title or âaboutâ page. A false story pretends to be true so people believe it. If a story seems too silly to be real, check whether the site is satire. Never share just because something is exciting. Stop, check, then decide.
Step
What to do
1
Read the claim and note who says it
2
Check author, date and evidence
3
Ask: do two other trusted sources agree?
4a
Yes: share with care
4b
No or not sure: do not share; ask an adult or teacher
Worked examples
Source
What it says
School website
No change in dates
Town council notice
Normal term time
The viral post
Closing for a month
A claim travels. An invented post says âSchools will close for one month next weekâ. Maya checks with two other sources.
Satire
False story
Purpose
make you laugh
make you believe
Does it say so?
yes, somewhere
no, it pretends to be real
Safe to share?
yes, if labelled as a joke
no
Satire or lie? A silly page says âTown replaces buses with giant snailsâ. Its About page says it is a joke site.
First postâCopyâCopyâCopy
A chain of copies is not two sources. Three posts that all copy the same first post are still one source.
Class activity
Two-source check (on paper). Your teacher or a parent invents a claim and writes it on a card, for example âLibraries will give out free bicyclesâ. You decide which kinds of source you would use to check it. Draw a table with three columns: Source kind, What it might say, How much I trust it and why. Rate each as high, medium or low. Then decide whether to share the claim. Finally, write one sentence you would send to a friend who wants to forward it. If you have a computer or tablet, you may read the headings of two pages on a safe subject with an adult, but do not share anything.
Practice
1
Why are three posts that copy the same article not three sources?
They all come from one original, so if it is wrong, all three are wrong. Independent sources do their own checking.
2
Name three different kinds of source you could use to check a claim about a local event.
For example: the council or school notice, a local newspaper, a library or museum, an official organisation. Any three kinds are correct.
3
A site says âNews: Local dog wins gold medal for nappingâ and its About page says âWe write jokesâ. Is it lying? What should you do before sharing?
Headline
About page
Local dog wins gold medal for napping
We write jokes
It is satire, not an attempt to deceive, if it clearly says so. Share only with a note that it is a joke, or not at all, because others may think it is real.
4
Your friend says âTwo of my friends sent me this, so it must be true.â What would you say?
Friends passing on a story does not prove it. They may have copied it too. Check with trusted sources first, then decide.