Week 5 Ā· Unit 9.1: Personal responsibility in the digital world Ā· 3 lessons
2
Words, dates and pictures
Digital Literacy 9: Unit 9.1, objectives 9DW.01
GoalSpot clues in the headline, spelling, date, evidence and pictures that suggest a story is inaccurate.
New words
headline Ā· the title of a story, written to catch attentionevidence Ā· facts, data or named sources that support a claimout of date Ā· once true, but not true nowcaption Ā· words that explain a picture
Explanation
Inaccurate stories often leave clues. An emotional headline such as āYou will not BELIEVE this!ā tries to make you feel before you think. Many spelling and grammar mistakes suggest the page was not checked. Look at the date: an old story shared as news can be out of date. Look for evidence: named experts, numbers with their source, a link to the original report. A photo can be real but have the wrong caption: a picture of one event used for another. No single clue proves a story is false, and a real story can contain a typing mistake. But several clues together should make you stop and check before you share.
Clue
Question to ask
Headline
Does it try to shock me?
Spelling
Has anyone checked it?
Date
Is it still true today?
Evidence
Who says so, and how do they know?
Photo
Does the picture match the words?
Worked examples
An invented hoax post. Several clues are circled: the date, the shouting headline and the photo caption.
Report A
Report B
The Marlow bridge opened on 3 May, said the town council. Pictures were taken by the local paper.
Bridge opens! Everybody knows its the best bridge ever! No one will tell you the truth.
Real news usually names its sources. Compare two reports of an invented bridge opening.
Photo
Real caption
Wrong caption
crowd at a school sports day
Sports day, Hillside School, last June
Crowd waits for concert tickets today
A real photo with the wrong caption.
Class activity
Clue hunt (in pairs, on paper). One person writes an invented false news story about a made-up event, for example āa town bans bicyclesā. Include at least four clues from the lesson (emotional headline, spelling, old date, no evidence, wrong caption). The partner circles each clue and says what the clue suggests. Then the writer rewrites the story as a trustworthy report with a named source, a date and a calm headline. Compare both versions in a table. All details are invented.
Practice
1
Which three clues make this story suspect? āSHOCKING!!! Scientist prooves that chocolate cures all illness. Posted 7 years ago, no source.ā
SHOCKING!!! Scientist prooves that chocolate cures all illness. (posted 7 years ago, no source)
The shouting headline, the spelling mistake (āproovesā), and the missing source with an old date. Also āall illnessā is too big a claim.
2
The caption says āFloods in our town this morningā but the photo shows a street with dry pavements and people in summer clothes. What is wrong and what should you do?
The picture does not match the words. Do not share it. Check with trusted local news or the council, and ask where the photo came from.
3
A story has one spelling mistake but names its author, its sources and the date. Should you reject it? Explain.
No. One clue is not proof. The author, sources and date give evidence. Still check one more source if the story matters.
4
Why is a very emotional headline a warning? Give a reason with ābecauseā.
Because it tries to make you share it quickly, before you think or check. Real reports are usually calmer and give facts first.